From mboxrd@z Thu Jan 1 00:00:00 1970 Received: from mout.web.de (mout.web.de [212.227.15.3]) (using TLSv1.2 with cipher ECDHE-RSA-AES256-GCM-SHA384 (256/256 bits)) (No client certificate requested) by smtp.subspace.kernel.org (Postfix) with ESMTPS id 34E5C4CDDEE; Wed, 30 Sep 2026 12:26:42 +0000 (UTC) Authentication-Results: smtp.subspace.kernel.org; arc=none smtp.client-ip=212.227.15.3 ARC-Seal:i=1; a=rsa-sha256; d=subspace.kernel.org; s=arc-20240116; t=1790771207; cv=none; b=WuMF8U1+sifSopA1eNZgpjOkUW4xmmZTct461LnzTq6WTjr0OeVsz/w0LtdmK1hL1pjdRp37WPk5g5e0HLBhLRsSI/tA4X4FCv+Megy19XJQZXHcDKiORFPlbFv41kC2HfdTow1JFRL3csk213rd2LqyNUJRi2YqI/0CLqTZk7c= ARC-Message-Signature:i=1; a=rsa-sha256; d=subspace.kernel.org; s=arc-20240116; t=1790771207; c=relaxed/simple; bh=yVxRvI9JVsWe/+h24RYwqxlTmD9+UjC3L6/yrCuPLjQ=; h=Message-ID:Date:MIME-Version:Subject:To:Cc:References:From: In-Reply-To:Content-Type; b=VesvGhdlkrSEW8frMWlC6jR7P6AlS6kKF3BdnuzBvgsrmIIgukzqp2ZMR6G4CmMzvdF/QSRHbueKblMQ4rG852AIjCNY0HHFpw5VN514cEDY/jS0TFTEBRoZjESrlr3Nlo8BMqLYRfio3uwPO8FfAclsSsmBXKn2zTb83D19Wiw= ARC-Authentication-Results:i=1; smtp.subspace.kernel.org; dmarc=pass (p=quarantine dis=none) header.from=web.de; spf=pass smtp.mailfrom=web.de; dkim=pass (2048-bit key) header.d=web.de header.i=markus.elfring@web.de header.b=Oagr8CmS; arc=none smtp.client-ip=212.227.15.3 Authentication-Results: smtp.subspace.kernel.org; dmarc=pass (p=quarantine dis=none) header.from=web.de Authentication-Results: smtp.subspace.kernel.org; spf=pass smtp.mailfrom=web.de Authentication-Results: smtp.subspace.kernel.org; dkim=pass (2048-bit key) header.d=web.de header.i=markus.elfring@web.de header.b="Oagr8CmS" DKIM-Signature: v=1; a=rsa-sha256; c=relaxed/relaxed; d=web.de; s=s29768273; t=1790771200; x=1791376000; i=markus.elfring@web.de; bh=9w6FdvLkFHDISQUf8R9Wx+ErljlSQRIrNMQGUpXNgTE=; h=X-UI-Sender-Class:Message-ID:Date:MIME-Version:Subject:To:Cc: References:From:In-Reply-To:Content-Type: Content-Transfer-Encoding:cc:content-transfer-encoding: content-type:date:from:message-id:mime-version:reply-to:subject: to; b=Oagr8CmS6GGuY7utBaJTb2973vvEr7v8MnCIE8X9qdLk+SHF/5wbyou4kKbh64k7 66wFb1v9fEyZq8P3nkOmNnigakUj53tNwgCw1czWH86hjXhJK3Y8dEq8dqpadHCFB VH7GqJFA9cFu4z9p+kbsXSO4eraucDb4yz3kzuUHaAzRkiea/UPWCNP8UP+SSnoff f0erUhUwxosrR1gNX13HfMR3XfSCYJFWKBoNyvHqO9T5tUxs1CuYiXxpngl7BHW29 EZMYgWeomt9WLoqySonC75yFIJL8Ft8CNbtZ/LjIlzRaMf5VlUjEsHs91u30wL8ou /P6NGwFlQVHUAstPkg== X-UI-Sender-Class: 814a7b36-bfc1-4dae-8640-3722d8ec6cd6 Received: from client.hidden.invalid by smtp.web.de (mrweb005 [213.165.67.108]) with ESMTPSA (Nemesis) id 1N1Lwd-1wjrpN0ufT-00vqlp; Wed, 30 Sep 2026 14:21:10 +0200 Message-ID: <1b56f03e-fab7-42a6-ac49-7b05a081639e@web.de> Date: Wed, 30 Sep 2026 14:21:08 +0200 Precedence: bulk X-Mailing-List: linux-kernel@vger.kernel.org List-Id: List-Subscribe: List-Unsubscribe: MIME-Version: 1.0 User-Agent: Mozilla Thunderbird Subject: Re: [v3] dmaengine: tegra186-gpc-dma: Read channel state under the lock To: Ginger Li , dmaengine@vger.kernel.org, linux-tegra@vger.kernel.org Cc: kernel-janitors@vger.kernel.org, LKML , Jonathan Hunter , Laxman Dewangan , Vinod Koul References: <20260929194434.29937-1-ginger.jzllee@gmail.com> <20260930071916.35722-1-ginger.jzllee@gmail.com> <0593ff86-c6ab-4c64-88a3-e500ed335760@web.de> Content-Language: en-GB, de-DE From: Markus Elfring In-Reply-To: Content-Type: text/plain; charset=UTF-8 Content-Transfer-Encoding: quoted-printable X-Provags-ID: V03:K1:zaqDEe7Z/wtfLmZd6KUx4w9WXEqBEnl21vt/UFY3LyZIwJ8oQHq 7uIAbIYx3IZQaF3kXWJp65NuzZPXjKjH9P8tX/7Xs6XfRHRpErwDEa+fQYrg8wTMazZafK8 hQBwb8JyH5qUGgyu99yk20333B/0eT8OYwKkZcHJNSaBktTXW2IQN1qTDz8gKFJII8ngU5Q SONtoHn43dQTFaFTqjbFw== X-Spam-Flag: NO UI-OutboundReport: notjunk:1;M01:P0:wrz1qXgXvkA=;clNzfxgy18WOpd5VMWValpS4LEQ 82B2uZ8MKv0+OzOexwHUWxQ50uSs1lSNl4ii4IQfxw5tV7mrMTNWDgpADZZfYvgJWOh+gcE3+ Bw/342LWcvibc54jqfpvqbqvIAi602i7tA0SOIA1+MzhZH5PbuCvmqwtxFux/9dgy29xIbk8j L9g6WEeu486aXPTmaEoD1T6r7LEICtoNmBS1c9gzwyr6pb2JfxjoQ0nQ9zXTCtYLPrxCiz896 n+WygeB9D5l2sD0wVOzIS7Gz1CFyUQmsuGqb6P0HY5RHA0roVHyr1LHJiZkCRHbqOnI584G/8 p1We6bSRuDMc1mWayGwJMMgBlb8PokArIUfbKso7y0Yar3QfjvYC+mZrNkImgb5QXZkW8tfC/ fhfScinD0poo5s99C8lQ7IWAeDaf9iYCRpgnwC6oK5oD2hhq7mG1tuawxrNmM6LmYAn4bYB/2 BohxccJ7J+sONXCHjEMQkw7dSk6bFD/UyKfYibM4tpaw1ljoqRTkj6uGksoJPAfuCVD4QfKN+ VxGh3qTXlAFC3TsFEM0qKFAKAMRDhzlcE/VN12BaDYnsk2eP/rVXPF+vDe56feZlX4+G0F+6q BMmfFzSEoXGKPcijMVqgMrxH1dLYQ2OjTI2tPfNu/I9kKRae8wERHELZwrdzEyvUj0hjE3Dr1 oXwvzLz266uUI42wHOgYR/RZ2+L59zGOlg80li1xC68+6xl4A+FgXuUz9JdIyUKfHTTOZNpla nEbIkRooxFnOHIcIdd6C6eTYGwxq7Ma7Z1uGLPDwPZPCdaVYkOaHxGhIEMnFDr2NC0jfKyiY8 nEKJBGsGWBrfOIsCdNBMmoVL9ZwSXrqbI65qSksTu6+uTJsQbzqIrSsG6cI3sWp15eYnHtHCI ui2iZ7ar16Q7gkRqlZKir4zuFwyfgDAXryD+t/+kypSBsuJnESDLk72jhsv/q2pmFIqXWc5pm lbjKX7TAS5tJfQsrjhbeTaBOF7IYJS8ZBPaN9zWa4tRk2Fe6xdEmOKaanVXc5LdklsSDNBAph /oxkAqBn97a4iH95l9u/tkmN6Ax2IeX6pqaWyiFjRQDg5UCp6rybKW74Aewh5BtloFFt1zbf+ RqQ7CC2Aqbe9LdDbEUWnL7vsj09E+tnPCE1gMFS/fsU7EOIpTnJJ4tF0KI7x4/F447nqV3gRp YsKi+5ffyOSQQkGvPkRF5YrMQ16uLTgYeunrBmJ41ctpyb5sqxqv26mKbnlvYuqiNLsIs8IrF wGY4FknHTJjBU9pviD9ipXReMPZfwJGPreZ0DZKZtdcK1v4X/75cWdhc8VJKLX4lbctvJSzWs 0vD82lVVyDBzOLNQuCziuz8M0jYWvWPG5lxYr+dO3M8HNK2AHjfetHGt1Co5mBflfZ4PbjDmz itxf64o/aE9pVZKrVfHntp0ZokW5QQQULuAJjX400kxU8O90s7DwgO5Wkmcb9F+9BG4ftUQdD y3HbbB+CmEZLNveBAhAsEqWJBqSNOrLsaqrvTNUGurL5y1gbv4daDJce5jkBdJj8rDs14cx5v mWM5vW7of3ND6gf9qSiGK4Ac1v5PFCtemdfD2hUSCyqv6b2ngU+ednYgl41u1Df70ABklu75I oy+Jnznp8d7gah6LCLhmLTX6PHDmVac17r35dkEnbiDODXq72UwVMHrMa9LpmCcNgrw2vr1J+ 5oIr1i89daKzL3VSrBptKkaXsrppgo3JXoIK/fYS+SKce38QTKWCv4Nex5SyugRtoiluWAPjh hLpd5QGz3/etbh/XFYjPD5sgoA9R/1+A5q3Dh3ln7w7NbnmZGDA4Pr0uFSb/VAVqkNtLIApql P9Ak8OSB9PnOaP5Qbt6yS92s3akWZ8YbqEDHy8rz3yu89WR4r+Wxc5B8/zwVjEFWswTjf88JI llZr0oCpO3oUVsCXrDLMolrhvqL0epQVwgVox6fNPXCwZj0vh/CtB72L4iQ8OxqSspTx0CMH3 pand8wH1YXStl5+cvWDjni47VNtK8hIj10mAmOHIEGBLNvgTHUMCTS8p6E3t6tqTlcBlP8sWd 2U4Xe2Taljrr8Q1gO0l+O5uxSNXkPFYrZZJcdaRrZsqQy2FUsfxnwxmrXUsUUbSz4stXICPFA aw9SOu6357EplKJ4xyl2ISV9D4gLauniivrVx2aK/MMubsEWuyW/88W5iZRFtSXNvXxOSxODt sJ7+K2VwvwRlRNTYiaM9vKqZvhiN7JMGHgFI+zBwt7V47OVWrAN8WdfCrkwFi7Gsgc5sTtlL4 wvP8faUNICUJTi6RbA+lXKeeRkI4mcAiodr3m2RDZq+WXqvOHvGJu75b3pq/g/dd77StVrR/p 6hzQ+6Yzqot8Cn94sZf6VVLjLi2Nw48ULshWNYYgZ+YwZpgSQgS9axThbKuN0DyDQ7nT+/c96 ExZDfoQFCe9YFSzAW+AOItP5BlNGn8/RSX8ijmNR1LrsG6j6XTNAkqzStkM1Kt9jmQolUf7VZ fOFlz3Q3VJiKlGNtr3Uw59Zi9idKQfOT5SInS34GP+mrAAGuMSuSVp9Bho7DVImoCWs38/531 alqYeZB52ZTWlJ/vc1GUS+rf3hs6GsOajsVAbIlEtsl/SUqLPLOcuQ7XcDIWEd31Ppuh7bd/H pFk5L5QHcON00WFUmfvOZz9ehuXwYIlUug/kd7yjKTKfoavKDdl6bhng+FrHaOGYT6Wn/6j3v v3cswi6g4FsBBEGaSaqiN36eBFiWF5wzYGs79JEFYxThH7UECphQ/CeDdW/wGraDguaQchmdI RvR+IRJwznWtc6X/kEMxuqkwuvbuUO65lS95CpbSVf95nQ8FJwW86jvRUL5rFvSwfqKGfv/Mi n+FAY1wsCxP5nwKFMR9qzhwTy8NIukXMyksvMfAaypMonv9VDzIXPW5tqe9NXPOWde/Zd2eEG ZVvqpxk94RF7VO5yYb6uU9FqFjAQ1qjuVAtO7gYIrLOXvmTjvWuKHaX2VxLfegaKiQGo15Oq+ RnMBbenP7FYS3Dac0dFKhGurF/E4vrTItddBUpdFVgCrunJBnXhWSWdQ/0jaQgMxSjb7AnZsg 8Te+tkOqkeE/0DtP1wENHohaJYMeHZWsApAMwjCLxxAnXVcbnVsljpf1ETx64D6q4yrSV98pt 4fAAsK8xrLCWuyJKG2MknI69FFr9bjDpOQ1vPW+rvWWHsLrs2/ZocpSSROkIqLpv5ZCooq0Uz PD4WmLMX5bA4eSk4dEvpEBLgieY0JEBNf4NtqJSnWVTME5r/VodJOIYywld410qmDyjnTGrJ3 pnzeagQEruDou09xtfJhpLFCsR+ATB8lwyPPez/XWX9flt2dbDfHyWm2pORdNuoDpxn6SufXL mWCKHD/CjHWWAyBSD7ehxtbaus9pFsfFexGRwoGjrbs68J/S2H7vEmZVZqaelAdxnANrPOI0W 9AvorpeBi7zk4+6pC8I/Po41tJE6oiH0spYau2Lu0BSDv4xUYCAQb5EfWDKDheqcAqt4K925a zs/KlifzEiD7YILsAve2GfOz1iU29+LXoOKHGS6dX+wTXI+h2wby6f/msssFkwe1Hoo+dRtcv 6mCo5si1n5RxDJg9UTkYgePEEuW8P6u0CQdj8cOlXMgWWSmBJn627xF+IjxK4pYB1Wj6wAJad o0q3AyFwi0PtBXT6eBnMNRCunay3ar/I+crUZ7atei7YtWUklZ8luXT9NckhTAusvjUl7ZRkW cjqkMtgXI5w4zpeSWSe5hpF3xeRA3Go4UiCzipkosAqIaa0GDiM/e9JwUodzv6ondVQHgVblI myb6sjpx9OhNIIwalv9qh54cdC2l8ua+jxp3XFSmf/h7l7yPkDA2Ifj0hWttngKo0JdmWAaO6 fqZAGso8UMqJy/r4Zd1wpDkrHRkGErYUtSbkW9zr6DD7eww3poO7Cy5Y1eHKxmzuTv/dcLPEZ htEf+jxPwvp3pBWliSNhszIocKgIXAU+S62Cv3I9ZhQAAz7uiULf4D4Hz1QvGdZ8OwcFtpBZK vScz//mDYT7FYMCHOQ521GI43G5lAWLPGxxkiMCD1hK9+LPpU78LIlLvbPXcww2zlbs4P8ARA ROXJnGQJCVZZuEu81gW2Oa4tBby8RCjrXmbC2kozE6yKkiwmVmUfuwZyM9OlbLcaX7M+YVhIl tFvL3yJXDAMphQgjVkHgFYIi0X2VtYnSHdXmuWK/pqnKU9U9RVkssvlH+h8qpTZukR25xfQWQ 2+xbz02vOnpnvKzzx2ScaKmPq24qUTuWA7bkcahzoySl5ndSuxiX9LS99l9y7EqbX4SXl9aPb dR7JE+Wp8kmiRrGxt6NTL37HVzkpl8n/6FzG+JhP4fSIi+2hqYI+zxUTjUvSOnfr66IOhjskd Zy2V4it3q83Wyfo0efDkDAw0squYfI/5jTwD+iBjaNgPIVg5mT2GwACr0qO35ymAeLUbg4XN/ Hi4CF6fB84qHG/UkSo9XXpCcmaOh5g7Q0LD57xJhDFLtTT3DpNOW63dvXBDHD3EYUbaDP9aJN iSqYMyLLitsUZT/p4TOlSjuC1zX0MsLHUpf4YO74X7AXpG2uvzJ2KxeYAvEkSljfKTbZgAAoH 7/Gu8v1a3P4pswyECc64blKPg1W9QDBlxL02ug4FPS4tnY3KSOdQ7DxvJTdsfsVjO3UlTFzuk UsEiFRoD7tnZIwM9JUV7FFqyjpwEs08jb219Pp8NpQWvR05eRqprIrjbPzp0VnmzJ52jUsYcn 1zBDY0Xq061b5NMEunnzY1rH9KkkQtmIlB04XT3KeHyxbWtb8AUCBA1JFw5XfMaNReylp4c1y eNcIEUU0LZ90aAT9LimDDB1gB3Hf0KBNJ8o9xENhBRnfL4T7G6qprTQAWd+Jsg6azN7UzSViu +r9MH2h9Nhxz37u4zlB2RYVKcTu8G7omiOsyUoup6p0uD9LmZGiCB3I6+wzvEA5SDyf4rvsXx U+PbgyKdgMH3pR0JTi2doDLd7siRsAhmaPMRrqZudUnzybzI17htaqA3fM6jBQ3fd7cHjAbLV qo2OgUl/OAj+9SwGHrh1nm0s8weXEfOS2TWpdf8lXAl97oou9ty6eNan2Z2lFShAt/MfLsUMU dym4wgUFBg3Raf68C6NwMilBZOHukXxgiusIkw5qi0TW6VAcjc3r3vcvaqTXRK1l1qyeh5APt OvskJF25nfqdCviaVnDMYx7kGr7jjZoR4+vf+keTct3k6mLmePnM+BI11lGHLwCQrCoNJvTbh jgsK/8dqaYfehANbMAXTml7aGQrmrQbbTNtCfP6ThWt52AF6qPCkxmdXTn/ZLLPoBdrAZTRai OX9SFdCfQblnA09TMRUw4ty+qZWf3lFfIW4ScKZo0z7Mg37wGbXncKhGEjEKYvj5AhFmMtX/E 2MT+KIeuAx92dwp7wRn4gjleV79PFpUMJ6Xo4SqnzKM6j6iBD7g6/zwljIrb1va4v/oV5xA2H +beltYuxv3bAhY6BI5OzsS0pytCxANa2kIjE5aovspLh9NmWfRQLVfNTh21u/ohEoqDCmJqvt iYRGjYKll2c+eZmpiAa5KOPOyeGpFRJnUrpxgPAPum5DUhk26B2LdXTcw8zI6lWNBQKmBv48U WUb8i1GcL0+v4+ulfsH3N4qmBPDrYP7isIO0nYo5W2MJt3imrbd13BPyOB+hGUy1OpMvvEVf1 8QXvEIlTHp67ijRS7DMQKZ46IUaKVNlmp2Q13JzQEBSbNs6Xcf8aQpelborMLDdlD101gmfFO nR/uZiF+liVbKlsfxvQKiiZN3uBqEqka7A9KedsuhGwawvmp2iUk/zyCfk29z7vgD/KpIHb4i dFWR63oD211BgmHlmEYc9NXy9VbFk3nOXr3CG+miZ77mfQ5I88ELQvlDOhFOJmjGygfNhQdO0 VPrhBz+Yg4U5kNRynAeHawobwJFHmj4LhL6n/KwgjwinaM5GygicAOM3sV4Be/qUW9iHQMyfh Age8qbvSq1KOoJKjoxET/m1TPsrSfUfuw6NyWBl6zLBbLbhz59010yRVzBzIIQeUcy8G7VnDP KwzBqwRHq8tin7TQRIy4OS8wJGi19MV168tW5cc7+YwDvL5S6uqslBGnrCID1u3DjIKoz8m1H ogjRUneXhmzFAFIp3ArU97MsCZZrCKlk0PBkRaRKbBQ7+6D7TMPsL9l43AMEU08f1AX5MT/He rLOsASB2MIf7BK7zDTzEqpKDeZ6cu5CLtz1U+J/HIU07IhWN+rdhOHLiZiK6IvjvI7NDJMseE BFpx6bxTWWzGTg7Cqh/BPgf5052nyCv8C8YEpdCx9OhfEyXyhzP98Am4eEDjbADwNjHVyvQKK GLR8j4IfivLx4uxaKam0DoiHtuEvvGRFDddbtsLNxuWvpPVKyWkKN/EBGzodF+yTDUGJ50b3c +Ap+NSWuImmf+Wo68VShv8ko+cY+f1x3SUyApbK3ovmcW/c7hGLSdF0hQKF8n8OAvTAoJBQaj XLJI >> How does this feedback fit to other known guidance? >> https://git.kernel.org/pub/scm/linux/kernel/git/torvalds/linux.git/tree= /Documentation/process/researcher-guidelines.rst?h=3Dv7.3-rc5#n5 >=20 > I can update more information about the static analyzer (i.e., it is > experimental and its reported log) in the patch. > I believe this aligns with the known guidance, Partly. How many contributors would be involved in the mentioned software research= so far? > but I cannot provide > the source code links. Do you try to follow scientific development methods? Will publishing requirements grow accordingly? >>>>> Were any more of your contributions supported by advanced source cod= e analysis tools? >>> >>> If you meant AI tools, then at this stage, no. For this patch, I have >>> used AI tools to help phrase >>> the patch better, but I did not use them for code analysis. >> Will this information trigger further collateral evolution? >=20 > The collateral evolution will only affect the experimental analyzer. > It does not affect the submitted patch. Will opportunities be taken better into account for improved change descri= ptions? Regards, Markus