I hate to say it but I think Hans might have the right answer here. As an administrator that has worked in large multi hundred million dollar companies where 1 hour of downtime == $75,000 in lost income proactive prevention IS the right answer. If the gcc people need to compile with the .96 rh version then they can apply a removal patch hans provides in the crash message. This makes it easy to remove the safeguard and blow yourself up at will after being suitibly called a dumbass. I do understand your desire to keep things simple and not put a safetynet out for every single moron out there. Personaly I despise them. But I also understand the evil necessity of doign this for somet hings that are this serious of a risk. From the debate raging here is what I gathered is acceptable.... make it blow up fataly and immediatly if it detects Red Hat + gcc 2.96-red_hat_broken(forgot version num) make it provide a URL to get the patch to remove this safeguard if you really want this. The fatal crash should be VERY carefull to only trigger on a redhat system with the broken compiler. And to satisfy your agument that people may need to be able to use it, provide a reverse patch to remove this safeguard in one easy cat file | patch. Brian Wolfe On Sat, Feb 03, 2001 at 01:06:52AM +0300, Hans Reiser wrote: > Alan Cox wrote: > > > > > As it stands, there is no way to determine programatically whether > > > gcc-2.96 is broken or now. The only way to do it is to check the RPM > > > version -- which, needless to say, is a bit difficult to do from the > > > C code about to be compiled. So I can't really blame Hans if he decides > > > to outlaw gcc-2.96[.0] for reiserfs compiles. > > > > Oh I can see why Hans wants to cut down his bug reporting load. I can also > > say from experience it wont work. If you put #error in then everyone will > > mail him and complain it doesnt build, if you put #warning in nobody will > > read it and if you dont put anything in you get the odd bug report anyway. > > > > Basically you can't win and unfortunately a shrink wrap forcing the user > > to read the README file for the kernel violates the GPL .. > > > > Jaded, me ? > > > > Alan > > I fear that you are speaking from experience about the complaints it doesn't > build, and that there is a strong element of truth in what you say. > > That said, my opinion is that bug reporting load is not as important as bug > avoidance, but I understand your position has merit to it also. > > Hans