mirror of https://lore.kernel.org/lkml/
 help / color / mirror / Atom feed
From: Ingo Molnar <mingo@elte.hu>
To: Con Kolivas <kernel@kolivas.org>
Cc: Serge Belyshev <belyshev@depni.sinp.msu.ru>,
	Al Boldi <a1426z@gawab.com>, Mike Galbraith <efault@gmx.de>,
	linux-kernel@vger.kernel.org, Nicholas Miell <nmiell@comcast.net>,
	Linus Torvalds <torvalds@linux-foundation.org>,
	Andrew Morton <akpm@linux-foundation.org>
Subject: Re: is RSDL an "unfair" scheduler too?
Date: Sat, 17 Mar 2007 17:34:34 +0100	[thread overview]
Message-ID: <20070317163434.GB30162@elte.hu> (raw)
In-Reply-To: <200703172343.53480.kernel@kolivas.org>


* Con Kolivas <kernel@kolivas.org> wrote:

> Ok but please look at how it appears from my end (illness aside).

( i really think we should continue this debate after you get better. 
  Everything looks much darker when you are ill! )

> You initially said you were pleased with this design.

I said that 2 years ago about the staircase scheduler and i am still 
saying this about RSDL today. That doesnt make my position automatically 
correct though :-) For example i wrote and maintained the 4g:4g patchset 
for over 2 years and still that was no guarantee of it making sense 
upstream ;) And it was a hell of a lot of work (much uglier and nastier 
work than any scheduler hacking and tuning, believe me), and it was 
thrown away as a cute but unnecessary complication we dont need. So 
what? To me what matters is the path you walk, not the destination you 
reach.

in terms of RSDL design, i like it, still i'm kind of asking myself 
'couldnt something in this direction be done in a much simpler and less 
revolutionary way'? For example couldnt we introduce per-priority level 
timeslice quotas in the current scheme as well, instead of the very 
simplistic and crude STARVATION_LIMIT approach? Furthermore, couldnt we 
make the timeslices become smaller as the runqueue length increases, to 
make starvation less of a problem? It seems like the problem cases with 
the current scheduler arent so much centered around the interactivity 
estimator, it is more that timeslices get distributed too coarsely, 
while RSDL distributes timeslices in a more finegrained way and is thus 
less suspect to starvation under certain workloads.

in any case, regardless the technical picture, i do get nervous when a 
group of people tries to out-shout clearly valid feedback like Mike's, 
and i'll try to balance such effects out a bit. _Of course_ those people 
that are not happy with the current scheduler have a higher likelyhood 
to try out another scheduler and be happy about it - but we should not 
allow that natural bias (which, btw., could easily be the _truth_, so 
i'm not assuming anything) to stand in the way of critical thinking. I 
also get slightly nervous about what appears to be dubious technical 
claims like "this is X's fault and if you rewrite X it will work much 
better so go away and do not stand in the way of progress" or "this new 
scheduler does away with all those ugly heuristics". I'm almost getting 
a reiser4 de ja vu :-/

we should really let this sit through in -mm for at least one more 
kernel iteration, let more folks be exposed to it and keep an eye on 
regression reports. [ An _eye_, not a machine gun ;-) ]

	Ingo

  reply	other threads:[~2007-03-17 16:34 UTC|newest]

Thread overview: 197+ messages / expand[flat|nested]  mbox.gz  Atom feed  top
2007-03-04 20:35 [ANNOUNCE] RSDL completely fair starvation free interactive cpu scheduler Al Boldi
2007-03-04 21:49 ` Con Kolivas
     [not found]   ` <45EB45F7.3050208@simon.arlott.org.uk>
2007-03-04 22:27     ` Con Kolivas
2007-03-05 18:29       ` Simon Arlott
2007-03-05 21:36         ` Con Kolivas
2007-03-04 23:13   ` Willy Tarreau
2007-03-04 23:58     ` Con Kolivas
2007-03-05  0:10     ` [ck] " jos poortvliet
2007-03-05  1:09     ` Gene Heskett
     [not found] ` <200703050834.45712.a1426z@gawab.com>
     [not found]   ` <20070305060732.GQ30401@nysv.org>
2007-03-05 11:59     ` [ck] " Al Boldi
2007-03-05 12:29       ` Con Kolivas
     [not found]         ` <200703052123.01095.a1426z@gawab.com>
2007-03-05 22:10           ` Con Kolivas
2007-03-06  8:42             ` Xavier Bestel
2007-03-06 15:15               ` Al Boldi
2007-03-11 18:11                 ` Al Boldi
2007-03-11 21:52                   ` Con Kolivas
2007-03-11 22:12                     ` Con Kolivas
2007-03-12  4:42                       ` Al Boldi
2007-03-12  4:53                         ` Con Kolivas
2007-03-12 11:26                           ` Al Boldi
2007-03-12 12:52                             ` Con Kolivas
2007-03-12 14:14                               ` Al Boldi
2007-03-12 14:58                                 ` [ck] " jos poortvliet
2007-03-12 16:37                                   ` michael chang
2007-03-12 17:41                                   ` Al Boldi
2007-03-12 18:05                                 ` Con Kolivas
2007-03-12 18:47                                   ` [ck] " jos poortvliet
2007-03-12 18:58                                     ` Antonio Vargas
2007-03-19 10:47                                       ` Helge Hafting
2007-03-18  1:30                               ` Bill Davidsen
2007-03-18 10:50                               ` [ck] " jos poortvliet
2007-03-13 15:31                             ` [PATCH] [RSDL-0.30] sched: rsdl improve latencies with differential nice Con Kolivas
2007-03-13 16:03                               ` [PATCH] [RSDL-0.30] sched: rsdl improve latencies with differential nice -1 Con Kolivas
2007-03-13 16:08                                 ` Con Kolivas
2007-03-13 20:58                                 ` Con Kolivas
2007-03-13 23:08                                   ` RSDL development plans Con Kolivas
2007-03-16 12:25                                     ` Con Kolivas
2007-03-16 13:40                                       ` RSDL v0.31 Con Kolivas
2007-03-16 15:34                                         ` Mike Galbraith
2007-03-16 21:13                                           ` Con Kolivas
2007-03-16 22:30                                             ` Mike Galbraith
2007-03-16 23:05                                               ` [ck] " Dirk Schoebel
2007-03-17  4:24                                               ` Nicholas Miell
2007-03-17  5:56                                                 ` Mike Galbraith
2007-03-17  6:08                                                   ` Mike Galbraith
2007-03-17 13:56                                                     ` Ed Tomlinson
2007-03-18 19:37                                                     ` Lee Revell
2007-03-18 19:55                                                       ` Mike Galbraith
2007-03-18 22:45                                                       ` Szonyi Calin
2007-03-19  2:27                                                     ` David Schwartz
2007-03-19  6:21                                                       ` Mike Galbraith
2007-03-19  6:59                                                         ` Willy Tarreau
2007-03-17  6:26                                                   ` Nicholas Miell
2007-03-17  7:11                                                     ` Mike Galbraith
2007-03-17  7:25                                                       ` William Lee Irwin III
2007-03-17  7:29                                                         ` Nicholas Miell
2007-03-17 11:48                                                       ` Gene Heskett
2007-03-17  7:45                                                     ` Ingo Molnar
2007-03-17  7:44                                                       ` David Lang
2007-03-17  8:46                                                         ` Mike Galbraith
2007-03-17 14:09                                                           ` [ck] " Mark Glines
2007-03-17 14:33                                                             ` Mike Galbraith
2007-03-17 14:54                                                               ` Mark Glines
2007-03-17 14:58                                                                 ` Mike Galbraith
2007-03-17  8:23                                                       ` Nicholas Miell
2007-03-17  9:42                                                         ` [patch] CFS scheduler: Completely Fair Scheduler / CONFIG_SCHED_FAIR Ingo Molnar
2007-03-17  8:41                                                       ` RSDL v0.31 Serge Belyshev
2007-03-17  9:48                                                         ` Con Kolivas
2007-03-17  9:58                                                           ` Mike Galbraith
2007-03-17 10:49                                                             ` Mike Galbraith
2007-03-17 12:05                                                               ` Gene Heskett
2007-03-17 13:36                                                                 ` Mike Galbraith
2007-03-17 17:03                                                                   ` Gene Heskett
2007-03-17 17:37                                                                     ` Mike Galbraith
2007-03-17 18:23                                                                       ` [ck] " Kacper Wysocki
2007-03-17 18:45                                                                         ` Mike Galbraith
2007-03-17 13:58                                                             ` michael chang
2007-03-17 20:55                                                             ` Al Boldi
2007-03-18  6:17                                                               ` Mike Galbraith
2007-03-18  6:47                                                                 ` Kasper Sandberg
2007-03-18  7:08                                                                   ` Mike Galbraith
2007-03-18  7:22                                                                     ` [ck] " Radoslaw Szkodzinski
2007-03-18  7:38                                                                       ` Mike Galbraith
2007-03-18  8:04                                                                         ` Mike Galbraith
2007-03-18  8:20                                                                         ` jimmy bahuleyan
2007-03-18  8:34                                                                           ` Mike Galbraith
2007-03-18  9:57                                                                         ` Kasper Sandberg
2007-03-18 13:57                                                                           ` Avuton Olrich
2007-03-19 20:47                                                                           ` Bill Davidsen
2007-03-20 10:19                                                                             ` jos poortvliet
2007-03-21  8:58                                                                             ` Kasper Sandberg
2007-03-18 15:44                                                                         ` Radoslaw Szkodzinski
2007-03-18 16:09                                                                           ` jos poortvliet
2007-03-19 16:07                                                               ` Mark Lord
2007-03-19 16:26                                                                 ` Xavier Bestel
2007-03-19 16:36                                                                   ` Mark Lord
2007-03-19 16:43                                                                     ` Xavier Bestel
2007-03-20  3:11                                                                       ` Linus Torvalds
2007-03-20  6:11                                                                         ` Willy Tarreau
2007-03-20  8:03                                                                           ` Mike Galbraith
2007-03-21 14:57                                                                             ` Mike Galbraith
2007-03-21 16:02                                                                               ` Peter Zijlstra
2007-03-21 17:06                                                                                 ` Mike Galbraith
2007-03-22  7:07                                                                                 ` Mike Galbraith
2007-03-22  9:18                                                                                   ` Ingo Molnar
2007-03-22  9:34                                                                                     ` Mike Galbraith
2007-03-22  9:41                                                                                       ` Mike Galbraith
2007-03-22 22:03                                                                                     ` Con Kolivas
2007-03-22 22:50                                                                                   ` Con Kolivas
2007-03-23  4:39                                                                                     ` Mike Galbraith
2007-03-23  5:59                                                                                       ` Con Kolivas
2007-03-23  6:11                                                                                         ` Mike Galbraith
2007-03-23 12:17                                                                                         ` Mike Galbraith
     [not found]                                                                               ` <20070321161147.54c7a727@localhost>
2007-03-21 17:07                                                                                 ` Mike Galbraith
2007-03-22  4:49                                                                                   ` Willy Tarreau
2007-03-22  7:14                                                                                     ` Mike Galbraith
2007-03-20  9:03                                                                           ` Xavier Bestel
2007-03-20 12:31                                                                             ` Artur Skawina
2007-03-20 19:16                                                                               ` Artur Skawina
2007-03-21  7:50                                                                             ` Ingo Molnar
2007-03-21 10:43                                                                               ` David Schwartz
2007-03-28 23:37                                                                                 ` Bill Davidsen
2007-03-29  7:10                                                                                   ` David Schwartz
2007-03-29  7:34                                                                                     ` Nick Piggin
2007-03-20 15:31                                                                           ` Linus Torvalds
2007-03-20 18:08                                                                             ` Al Boldi
2007-03-21  8:22                                                                             ` Keith Duthie
2007-03-28 23:43                                                                             ` Bill Davidsen
2007-03-20 10:26                                                                         ` [ck] " jos poortvliet
2007-03-20 13:22                                                                         ` Mark Lord
2007-03-20 15:16                                                                           ` Ray Lee
2007-03-20 15:20                                                                             ` Mark Lord
2007-03-21  8:55                                                                             ` Kasper Sandberg
2007-03-19 20:53                                                                 ` Al Boldi
2007-03-20 19:50                                                                   ` Artur Skawina
2007-03-21  4:15                                                                     ` Al Boldi
2007-03-21 17:24                                                                       ` Artur Skawina
2007-03-19 16:03                                                             ` Mark Lord
2007-03-17 11:49                                                           ` is RSDL an "unfair" scheduler too? Ingo Molnar
2007-03-17 12:02                                                             ` Con Kolivas
2007-03-17 12:23                                                               ` [ck] " jos poortvliet
2007-03-17 17:31                                                                 ` David Schwartz
2007-03-17 12:28                                                               ` Ingo Molnar
2007-03-17 12:43                                                                 ` Con Kolivas
2007-03-17 16:34                                                                   ` Ingo Molnar [this message]
2007-03-18  3:23                                                                     ` Bill Davidsen
2007-03-18  2:13                                                                   ` Bill Davidsen
2007-03-18  3:20                                                                     ` Kasper Sandberg
2007-03-18  5:37                                                                     ` Mike Galbraith
2007-03-18 10:58                                                                       ` [ck] " jos poortvliet
2007-03-17 12:15                                                             ` jos poortvliet
2007-03-17 20:41                                                             ` Avi Kivity
2007-03-18  1:25                                                               ` William Lee Irwin III
2007-03-18  1:32                                                                 ` Linus Torvalds
2007-03-18  5:24                                                                   ` Willy Tarreau
2007-03-18  5:55                                                                     ` Avi Kivity
2007-03-19  2:27                                                                       ` David Schwartz
2007-03-19 13:27                                                                         ` Radoslaw Szkodzinski
2007-03-19 18:30                                                                           ` David Lang
2007-03-19 15:25                                                                         ` Avi Kivity
2007-03-19 16:06                                                                           ` Helge Hafting
2007-03-19 16:37                                                                             ` Avi Kivity
2007-03-18  6:09                                                                     ` Bill Huey
2007-03-18  6:37                                                                       ` Mike Galbraith
2007-03-18  7:35                                                                         ` Bill Huey
2007-03-19 21:14                                                                       ` Bill Davidsen
2007-03-18  6:26                                                                     ` Mike Galbraith
2007-03-18  6:54                                                                       ` [ck] " Radoslaw Szkodzinski
2007-03-18  7:58                                                                         ` Willy Tarreau
2007-03-18  8:45                                                                           ` Avi Kivity
2007-03-18  5:00                                                                 ` Avi Kivity
2007-03-17 15:13                                                           ` RSDL v0.31 Mark Hahn
2007-03-17 17:22                                                             ` Stephen Clark
2007-03-19 15:06                                                             ` Chris Friesen
2007-03-17  7:56                                                     ` Ingo Molnar
2007-03-17 11:07                                                       ` [ck] " jos poortvliet
2007-03-17 12:44                                                         ` Ingo Molnar
2007-03-17 13:44                                                           ` jos poortvliet
2007-03-17 14:04                                                         ` [ck] " Ed Tomlinson
2007-03-17 14:32                                               ` Rik van Riel
2007-03-17 14:43                                                 ` Mike Galbraith
2007-03-17 15:39                                                 ` Ingo Molnar
2007-03-16 17:12                                         ` AshMilsted
2007-03-16 17:41                                           ` Gabriel C
2007-03-16 21:55                                         ` Al Boldi
2007-03-17  2:51                                           ` Con Kolivas
2007-03-17  4:40                                             ` Al Boldi
2007-03-17  4:57                                               ` Con Kolivas
2007-03-17  5:15                                                 ` Gene Heskett
2007-03-17 13:50                                                 ` Ed Tomlinson
2007-03-17 16:12                                                 ` Al Boldi
2007-03-16 13:42                                       ` RSDL development plans Mike Galbraith
2007-03-16 13:59                                         ` Con Kolivas
2007-03-16 14:07                                           ` Mike Galbraith
2007-03-14  9:13                               ` [PATCH] [RSDL-0.30] sched: rsdl improve latencies with differential nice Mike Galbraith
2007-03-14  9:25                                 ` Con Kolivas
2007-03-14  9:42                                   ` Mike Galbraith

Reply instructions:

You may reply publicly to this message via plain-text email
using any one of the following methods:

* Save the following mbox file, import it into your mail client,
  and reply-to-all from there: mbox

  Avoid top-posting and favor interleaved quoting:
  https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Posting_style#Interleaved_style

* Reply using the --to, --cc, and --in-reply-to
  switches of git-send-email(1):

  git send-email \
    --in-reply-to=20070317163434.GB30162@elte.hu \
    --to=mingo@elte.hu \
    --cc=a1426z@gawab.com \
    --cc=akpm@linux-foundation.org \
    --cc=belyshev@depni.sinp.msu.ru \
    --cc=efault@gmx.de \
    --cc=kernel@kolivas.org \
    --cc=linux-kernel@vger.kernel.org \
    --cc=nmiell@comcast.net \
    --cc=torvalds@linux-foundation.org \
    /path/to/YOUR_REPLY

  https://kernel.org/pub/software/scm/git/docs/git-send-email.html

* If your mail client supports setting the In-Reply-To header
  via mailto: links, try the mailto: link
Be sure your reply has a Subject: header at the top and a blank line before the message body.
This is a public inbox, see mirroring instructions
for how to clone and mirror all data and code used for this inbox

all inboxes | Powered by JetHome®