Re: [PATCH] serial inter-character timeout usage with async io

[Alan Cox <alan@lxorguk.ukuu.org.uk>]

> A Linux program is connected via serial port to some other serial device
> using asynchronous I/O and the other serial device sends a 150 byte
> sequence to the Linux program. The Linux program will receive 18
> intermediate SIGIOs (one for each 8-byte threshold interrupt generated
> by the UART) followed by 1 final inter-character timeout (when the UART
> FIFO contains the last 6 bytes). The program upon each SIGIO would
> read() 8 bytes and do some parsing of the data buffer and realize that
> the whole sequence had not yet been received. Repeat 17 more times in
> this example.

That seems a particularly odd way to implement block I/O. Just use a
thread for this and the VMIN/VTIME functionality in the n_tty layer -
that is why it is there.

> I agree. However, the inter-character timeout is present (to the best of
> my knowledge and google's) in all serial UARTs from the 16550A onward
> (starting around 1994 and Windows 3.1). Before that, the IIR timeout

Almost all our drivers are not 16550A. A large part of the serial world
is now USB and current PCs (especially laptops) often don't include any
16550A devices at all.

Your changes seem to be - hardware specific, not supportable by many
devices, and designed to improve a particularly crazy way of handling the
I/O in the first place. That doesn't make a good candidate for the
upstream kernel.

Alan