Re: [PATCH 04/14] arch/tile: change lower bound on syscall error return to -4095

[Arnd Bergmann <arnd@arndb.de>]

On Friday 15 October 2010 19:17:19 Chris Metcalf wrote:
>  On 10/14/2010 5:22 PM, Arnd Bergmann wrote:
> > On Thursday 14 October 2010 21:14:29 Chris Metcalf wrote:
> >> Previously we were using -1023, which is fine for normal syscall
> >> error returns, but the common value in use for other platforms
> >> is -4095, and one Tilera-specific driver does use values in the
> >> -1100 range, so tickled this bug.
> > The patch is ok, but note that any value above starting at 512 is meant
> > as kernel internal, so funny things may happen if a driver goes
> > beyond that for errors returned to the user.
> >
> > Better use just the predefined error codes if possible.
> 
> Thanks, good point.  In practice we've found that for the syscalls we use
> (e.g. pwrite) that are intended to return errors codes from our drivers the
> errors are in fact properly returned.  But I've filed a bug internally that
> we should review our usage of error codes and determine if there are more
> standard ways to handle this, e.g. return a Linux errno but allow passing a
> pointer to store a more specific hypervisor or driver error code in.

I think in general I'd do something like return -EIO with a hardware or
hypervisor result code written to memory if that happens. In specific
drivers there may of course be a better way.

	Arnd