From: "Paul E. McKenney" <paulmck@kernel.org>
To: Alan Stern <stern@rowland.harvard.edu>
Cc: Jonas Oberhauser <jonas.oberhauser@huawei.com>,
"parri.andrea@gmail.com" <parri.andrea@gmail.com>,
"will@kernel.org" <will@kernel.org>,
"peterz@infradead.org" <peterz@infradead.org>,
"boqun.feng@gmail.com" <boqun.feng@gmail.com>,
"npiggin@gmail.com" <npiggin@gmail.com>,
"dhowells@redhat.com" <dhowells@redhat.com>,
"j.alglave@ucl.ac.uk" <j.alglave@ucl.ac.uk>,
"luc.maranget@inria.fr" <luc.maranget@inria.fr>,
"akiyks@gmail.com" <akiyks@gmail.com>,
"dlustig@nvidia.com" <dlustig@nvidia.com>,
"joel@joelfernandes.org" <joel@joelfernandes.org>,
"urezki@gmail.com" <urezki@gmail.com>,
"quic_neeraju@quicinc.com" <quic_neeraju@quicinc.com>,
"frederic@kernel.org" <frederic@kernel.org>,
Kernel development list <linux-kernel@vger.kernel.org>
Subject: Re: [PATCH] tools: memory-model: Add rmw-sequences to the LKMM
Date: Tue, 15 Nov 2022 20:58:49 -0800 [thread overview]
Message-ID: <20221116045849.GJ4001@paulmck-ThinkPad-P17-Gen-1> (raw)
In-Reply-To: <Y3O6mJz4wXJlzLh2@rowland.harvard.edu>
On Tue, Nov 15, 2022 at 11:13:12AM -0500, Alan Stern wrote:
> On Tue, Nov 15, 2022 at 02:05:39PM +0000, Jonas Oberhauser wrote:
> >
> >
> >
> >
> > > -----Original Message-----
> > > From: Alan Stern [mailto:stern@rowland.harvard.edu]
> > > Sent: Monday, November 14, 2022 6:26 PM
> >
> > Hi Alan,
> > thanks for preparing this!
> >
> > > Jonas has pointed out a weakness in the Linux Kernel Memory Model.
> > > Namely, the memory ordering properties of atomic operations are not
> > > monotonic: An atomic op with full-barrier semantics does not always provide ordering as strong as one with release-barrier semantics.
> >
> > Note that I believe it was Viktor who originally pointed out this weakness to me
> > in private communication. My contribution (besides chatting with you) is to
> > check that the solution does indeed restore the monotonicity (not just on some
> > litmus tests but in general).
> >
> > So I would change the wording to "Viktor has pointed out a weakness in the Linux
> > Kernel Memory Model."
>
> People will wonder who Viktor is. I don't have his full name or email
> address. In fact, shouldn't he have been CC'ed during this entire
> discussion?
Viktor Vafeiadis <viktor@mpi-sws.org>
But I defer to Jonas on CCing, just in case Viktor needs to be provided
context on this discussion.
Thanx, Paul
> > > +let rmw-sequence = (rf ; rmw)*
> >
> > I would perhaps suggest to only consider external read-from in rmw-sequences, as
> > below:
> > +let rmw-sequence = (rfe ; rmw)*
>
> We discussed the matter earlier, and I don't recall any mention of this
> objection.
>
> > The reason I (slightly) prefer this is that this is sufficient to imply
> > monotonicity.
> > Also there is some minor concern that the patch that results in the stricter
> > model (i.e., rmw-sequence = (rf ; rmw)*) might be incorrect on some hypothetical
> > future architecture in which RMWs can be merged in the store coalescing queue
> > with earlier stores to the same location. This is exemplified in the following
> > litmus test:
> >
> > C atomics-not-monotonic-2
> >
> > {}
> >
> > P0(int *x, atomic_t *y)
> > {
> > int r1;
> > WRITE_ONCE(*x, 1);
> > smp_store_release(y, 0);
> > r1 = atomic_inc_return_relaxed(y);
> > }
> >
> > P1(atomic_t *y)
> > {
> > int r1;
> >
> > r1 = atomic_inc_return(y);
> > }
> >
> > P2(int *x, atomic_t *y)
> > {
> > int r2;
> > int r3;
> >
> > r2 = atomic_read(y);
> > smp_rmb();
> > r3 = READ_ONCE(*x);
> > }
> >
> > exists (2:r2=2 /\ 2:r3=0)
> >
> > Here such a hypothetical future architecture could merge the operations to *y by
> > P0 into a single store, effectively turning the code of P0 into
> >
> > P0(int *x, atomic_t *y)
> > {
> > int r1;
> > WRITE_ONCE(*x, 1);
> > WRITE_ONCE(*y, 1);
> > r1 = 0;
> > }
> >
> > The stricter patch would not be sound with this hypothetical architecture, while
> > the more relaxed patch should be.
> >
> > I don't think such a future architecture is likely since I don't expect there to
> > be any practical performance impact. At the same time I also don't currently see
> > any advantage of the stricter model.
> >
> > For this reason I would slightly prefer the more relaxed model.
>
> I don't see any point in worrying about hypothetical future
> architectures that might use a questionable design.
>
> Also, given that this test is forbidden:
>
> P0 P1 P2
> ------------------------- -------------- ----------------------------
> WRITE_ONCE(*x, 1); atomic_inc(y); r1 = atomic_read_acquire(y);
> atomic_set_release(y, 1); r2 = READ_ONCE(*x);
> exists (2:r1=2 /\ 2:r2=0)
>
> shouldn't the following also be forbidden?
>
> P0 P1 P2
> ------------------------- -------------- ----------------------------
> WRITE_ONCE(*x, 1); atomic_inc(y); r1 = atomic_read_acquire(y);
> atomic_set_release(y, 1); atomic_inc(y); r2 = READ_ONCE(*x);
> exists (2:r1=3 /\ 2:r2=0)
>
> > > +Rmw sequences have a special property in the LKMM: They can extend the
> > > +cumul-fence relation. That is, if we have:
> > > +
> > > + U ->cumul-fence X -> rmw-sequence Y
> > > +
> > > +then also U ->cumul-fence Y. Thinking about this in terms of the
> > > +operational model, U ->cumul-fence X says that the store U propagates
> > > +to each CPU before the store X does. Then the fact that X and Y are
> > > +linked by an rmw sequence means that U also propagates to each CPU
> > > +before Y does.
> > > +
> >
> > Here I would add that the rmw sequences also play a similar role in the
> > w-post-bounded relation. For example as follows:
> >
> > +Rmw sequences have a special property in the LKMM: They can extend the
> > +cumul-fence and w-post-bounded relations. That is, if we have:
> > +
> > + U ->cumul-fence X -> rmw-sequence Y
> > +
> > +then also U ->cumul-fence Y, and analogously if we have
> > +
> > + U ->w-post-bounded X -> rmw-sequence Y
> > +
> > +then also U ->w-post-bounded Y. Thinking about this in terms of the
> > +operational model, U ->cumul-fence X says that the store U propagates
> > +to each CPU before the store X does. Then the fact that X and Y are
> > +linked by an rmw sequence means that U also propagates to each CPU
> > +before Y does.
> > +
>
> I considered this and specifically decided against it, because the
> w-post-bounded relation has not yet been introduced at this point in the
> document. It doesn't show up until much later. (Also, there didn't
> seem to be any graceful way of mentioning this fact at the point where
> w-post-bounded does get introduced, and on the whole the matter didn't
> seem to be all that important.)
>
> Instead of your suggested change, I suppose it would be okay to say, at
> the end of the paragraph:
>
> (In an analogous way, rmw sequences can extend the
> w-post-bounded relation defined below in the PLAIN ACCESSES
> AND DATA RACES section.)
>
> Or something like this could be added to the ODDS AND ENDS section at
> the end of the document.
>
> Alan
next prev parent reply other threads:[~2022-11-16 4:58 UTC|newest]
Thread overview: 6+ messages / expand[flat|nested] mbox.gz Atom feed top
2022-11-14 17:26 Alan Stern
2022-11-14 20:55 ` Boqun Feng
2022-11-15 14:05 ` Jonas Oberhauser
2022-11-15 16:13 ` Alan Stern
2022-11-16 4:58 ` Paul E. McKenney [this message]
2022-11-16 13:58 ` Jonas Oberhauser
Reply instructions:
You may reply publicly to this message via plain-text email
using any one of the following methods:
* Save the following mbox file, import it into your mail client,
and reply-to-all from there: mbox
Avoid top-posting and favor interleaved quoting:
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Posting_style#Interleaved_style
* Reply using the --to, --cc, and --in-reply-to
switches of git-send-email(1):
git send-email \
--in-reply-to=20221116045849.GJ4001@paulmck-ThinkPad-P17-Gen-1 \
--to=paulmck@kernel.org \
--cc=akiyks@gmail.com \
--cc=boqun.feng@gmail.com \
--cc=dhowells@redhat.com \
--cc=dlustig@nvidia.com \
--cc=frederic@kernel.org \
--cc=j.alglave@ucl.ac.uk \
--cc=joel@joelfernandes.org \
--cc=jonas.oberhauser@huawei.com \
--cc=linux-kernel@vger.kernel.org \
--cc=luc.maranget@inria.fr \
--cc=npiggin@gmail.com \
--cc=parri.andrea@gmail.com \
--cc=peterz@infradead.org \
--cc=quic_neeraju@quicinc.com \
--cc=stern@rowland.harvard.edu \
--cc=urezki@gmail.com \
--cc=will@kernel.org \
/path/to/YOUR_REPLY
https://kernel.org/pub/software/scm/git/docs/git-send-email.html
* If your mail client supports setting the In-Reply-To header
via mailto: links, try the mailto: link
Be sure your reply has a Subject: header at the top and a blank line
before the message body.
This is a public inbox, see mirroring instructions
for how to clone and mirror all data and code used for this inbox
all inboxes | Powered by JetHome®