Re: [PATCH] HSI: hsi_char: Fix use-after-free on device removal

[Greg KH <gregkh@linuxfoundation.org>]

On Thu, Aug 27, 2026 at 01:09:31PM +0800, Shengzhuo Wei wrote:
> On 2026-08-27 06:48, Greg KH wrote:
> 
> > You now have 2 reference counts for the same structure, which is not how
> > to handle this at all :(
> > 
> > Please either make the cdev be a pointer, or use the correct cdev api
> > for handling this type of common problem.
> 
> Right, adding the kref on top of the embedded cdev was the wrong call.
> Thanks for catching it.
> 
> I'd like to go with the pointer option, because of how this driver is
> structured: one hsc_client_data serves 16 minor numbers through a
> single cdev_add(&cl_data->cdev, hsc_dev, HSC_DEVS), and cdev_device_add()
> pairs one cdev with one struct device, so switching to it would mean
> inventing 16 device objects for no other purpose.
> 
> With a dynamically allocated cdev (cdev_alloc() in probe, cdev_del() in
> remove), the kobject reference that chrdev_open() already takes on the
> cdev would keep the containing object alive until the last file
> descriptor is closed, and the final release would go through the cdev's
> kobject release callback instead of a hand-written kref — no second
> reference count anywhere.
> 
> Does that sound like the right direction to you? If so I'll send a v2
> along those lines.

I'll defer to the hsi maintainers as to what they wish to do here.

Also, how do you remove a hsi device from the system?  Is this on a
dynamic bus?  For some reason I didn't think that was possible.

thanks,

greg k-h