Re: [PATCH net-next v2 2/5] dt-bindings: net: dsa: ksz: add mdio-parent-bus property for internal MDIO

[Andrew Lunn <andrew@lunn.ch>]

> > I'm not saying whether this is good or bad, I'm just worried about
> > mixing quantities having different measurement units into the same
> > address space.
> > 
> > Just like in the case of an mdio-mux, there is no address space isolation
> > between the parent bus and the child bus. AKA you can't have this,
> > because there would be clashes:
> > 
> > 	host_bus: mdio@abcd {
> > 		ethernet-phy@2 {
> > 			reg = <2>;
> > 		};
> > 	};
> > 
> > 	child_bus: mdio@efgh {
> > 		mdio-parent-bus = <&host_bus>;
> > 
> > 		ethernet-phy@2 {
> > 			reg = <2>;
> > 		};
> > 	};
> > 
> > But there is a big difference. With an mdio-mux, you could statically
> > detect address space clashes by inspecting the PHY addresses on the 2
> > buses. But with the lan937x child MDIO bus, in this design, you can't,
> > because the "reg" values don't represent MDIO addresses, but switch port
> > numbers (this is kind of important, but I don't see it mentioned in the
> > dt-binding).
> 
> In current state, the driver still require properly configured addresses
> in the devicetree. So, it will be visible in the DT.

This is not what i was expecting, especially from mv88e6xxx
perspective. The older generation of devices had the PHYs available on
the 'host bus', as well as the 'child bus', using a 1:1 address
mapping. You could in theory even skip the 'child bus' and list the
PHYs on the 'host bus' and phy-handle would make it work. However i
see from a later comment that does not work here, you need some
configuration done over SPI, which mv88e6xx does not need. 

> 
> > These are translated by lan937x_create_phy_addr_map() using
> > the CASCADE_ID/VPHY_ADD pin strapping information read over SPI.
> > I.e. with the same device tree, you may or may not have address space
> > clashes depending on pin strapping. No way to tell.
> 
> The PHY address to port mapping in the driver is needed to make the
> internal switch interrupt controller assign interrupts to proper PHYs.

You are talking about:

			ds->user_mii_bus->irq[phy] = irq;

in ksz_irq_phy_setup.

I naively expect 'phy' to be the 'reg' value in DT, and the 'dev'
value which passed to mdiobus_read_nested(bus, dev, reg) ?

	Andrew