From mboxrd@z Thu Jan 1 00:00:00 1970 Authentication-Results: smtp.subspace.kernel.org; arc=none smtp.remote-ip=212.227.15.18 ARC-Seal: i=1; d=subspace.kernel.org; s=arc20261015; a=rsa-sha256; cv=none; t=1793555221; b=DosL+nw+OpBxbU93y2ck8WO9JC1IPiI3FwmoOo6di58Bxmeb2pBBsl9JFSbi8bEkLfvp qrYkttK0jYY2gfP14cbskjWaxogEAWsQUEelvxHbYVT1A2mYgPnaCtp2kMK4yHxnr75Kx 7Y2cxBZzD5BI6+s+NFK9261d0xXBcnd3h9PFbYfPsfa2hdYZPE6bnanBOdxXGd4dlShFt Pjntaueo8OtJJXBGFQAYhIm/JEAwib9xeanAY7nH1jJKEy4mGkD8UD9VqYbJ73+PyX+LZ iNbngjhSQY35A0fcU6lg6nCNe15IRLiLggMrsp4KadrQxMgO304+e15ti7VxXYH8X5Q== ARC-Message-Signature: i=1; d=subspace.kernel.org; s=arc20261015; a=rsa-sha256; c=relaxed/relaxed; t=1793555221; h=DMARC-Filter:DKIM-Signature:X-UI-Sender-Class:Received:Message-ID: Subject:From:To:Cc:Date:In-Reply-To:References:Content-Type: Content-Transfer-Encoding:User-Agent:MIME-Version:X-Provags-ID: X-Spam-Flag:UI-OutboundReport; bh=PgehQJukNosBI4Ey8kn16RcxGKLh0w5urajR4XsZi9s=; b=K4SK/sStwMQ2PFJWBxmSu1W7l+EEKaHEWSNmMsoKZuq32M63CdzK5Spp72XFFlxLeb7b 7ZFHiD3zCC/KNqXST0JK/gLT730hwkowC2IZWoEE9HGHNT6QSs60htdKy6UbOVCq9RiEi ztJNJmi82rUaPu/HaMdHem1ukH5W2xu6MR7nxTCtb464hfIG5mWkYGLTCvxRHHEaVHOCP A4PuNe4vMrKb1AoDC4yfXcruUPJJh63VXeDTLCl5tqtqx6+BrVMnGI6nyBOBrjzXvlphO +Q7FTDiwgQ1RJwyT30Ie7k39P8vYbN1icozkzEGQaC0tE/2hQ0T4bvKg7dHNYuERaaA== ARC-Authentication-Results: i=1; smtp.subspace.kernel.org; dmarc=pass header.from=gmx.de; spf=pass smtp.mailfrom=gmx.de; dkim=pass header.d=gmx.de header.i=efault@gmx.de header.a=rsa-sha256 header.s=s31663417 header.b=V67f8RnV; arc=none smtp.remote-ip=212.227.15.18 Received: from mout.gmx.net (mout.gmx.net [212.227.15.18]) (using TLSv1.3 with cipher TLS_AES_256_GCM_SHA384 (256/256 bits) key-exchange ECDHE (prime256v1) server-signature ECDSA (prime256v1) server-digest SHA256) (No client certificate requested) by smtp.subspace.kernel.org (Postfix) with ESMTPS id E304A606A336 for ; Sun, 1 Nov 2026 17:46:59 +0000 (UTC) DMARC-Filter: OpenDMARC Filter v1.4.2 smtp.subspace.kernel.org E304A606A336 Authentication-Results: smtp.subspace.kernel.org; dmarc=pass (p=quarantine dis=none) header.from=gmx.de Authentication-Results: smtp.subspace.kernel.org; spf=pass smtp.mailfrom=gmx.de Authentication-Results: smtp.subspace.kernel.org; dkim=pass (2048-bit key, unprotected) header.d=gmx.de header.i=efault@gmx.de header.a=rsa-sha256 header.s=s31663417 header.b=V67f8RnV DKIM-Signature: v=1; a=rsa-sha256; c=relaxed/relaxed; d=gmx.de; s=s31663417; t=1793555205; x=1794160005; i=efault@gmx.de; bh=PgehQJukNosBI4Ey8kn16RcxGKLh0w5urajR4XsZi9s=; h=X-UI-Sender-Class:Message-ID:Subject:From:To:Cc:Date:In-Reply-To: References:Content-Type:Content-Transfer-Encoding:MIME-Version:cc: content-transfer-encoding:content-type:date:from:message-id: mime-version:reply-to:subject:to; b=V67f8RnV2LOmK+yh6x6egqrGU7ZRHQtvLNCz7FC2yq/Hnc5FxgoNHp4++XdwZC6j rk7Ka9XKkaLZCIVCC/EL4EIY9SDe9fI4M21AflehAssNRmirjeHE32BX3uIUnLLAJ H3RUsPQyPi7Ye1gyvdylFaiLyP+Nw19XaEcG1mFvViDiq3GQ2BUQ3FIOf412pGRII jJ4vsTBPxftJTSI5h3c0dU9GgbzevhJS91isZjn4EFhd7CXpVFWh3HgfNlEViYd7m V4MaiDd9ewpIFcbZFWhaFv6hJBU4DvLvib0csy5fiZlWt3yiWwt/Qv6e+FpLk/PW6 IWmLSP70hS1b4H7rYA== X-UI-Sender-Class: 724b4f7f-cbec-4199-ad4e-598c01a50d3a Received: from client.hidden.invalid by mail.gmx.net (mrgmx004 [212.227.17.190]) with ESMTPSA (Nemesis) id 1Mwwdl-1wcanW0gXr-010yMr; Sun, 01 Nov 2026 18:46:45 +0100 Message-ID: <455d642847fdee6e2a8b594597037c5db9791afa.camel@gmx.de> Subject: Re: [PATCH v3 7/7] sched/eevdf: Move to a single runqueue From: Mike Galbraith To: Chengfeng Lin , Vincent Guittot , Peter Zijlstra Cc: Ingo Molnar , Juri Lelli , linux-kernel@vger.kernel.org Date: Sun, 01 Nov 2026 18:46:43 +0100 In-Reply-To: References: <5ab06e4740bb0fd177a96e0a31f933a27d081012.camel@gmx.de> Content-Type: text/plain; charset="UTF-8" Content-Transfer-Encoding: quoted-printable User-Agent: Evolution 3.56.2 X-Mailing-List: linux-kernel@vger.kernel.org List-Id: List-Post: List-Help: List-Subscribe: List-Unsubscribe: List-Owner: Precedence: list MIME-Version: 1.0 X-Provags-ID: V03:K1:MFvIrVsixsVmCbVDXfcFZhlQk7b3d2Hd+o4c31sa5hKp7JBKznv 63YiYFNlDVxgVDuuChxOdCcKqSkZqHYQgAG27WUIOPdhaPZ4AHB2WcrbxDZgzKkSXvezaZG pTa5Tpt2iqg3M9D846febKzvqqjhtBRCzMYJOm/7CVM+whKHxiwGM0dwttyx7J0td0ULXzk LoEkC6IsZK3yVHsj8xvUA== X-Spam-Flag: NO UI-OutboundReport: notjunk:1;M01:P0:+HPSjuVTcTI=;XSnEC8CBPOek4c6sb8BCFStalDF v2kZ6WSlmdSFzvF8Bct5CimqidkQ/M0Dx5HqquOWOWFayj09Rbs5O0LhEanld0OMMDjk7c+5L dfWu/nX1/jfyJjFl0jboP1a2mJAELos8Rdlz5kk9YcawR23oB0IFFpqKsvsqcTs2otBPWaPBT JA7CZkqH+liLNUR53NF5Eg6FKlsR7GSOwAdt580i39mYkwpvWofMjhyGPmf9cwpE+7oWEXRBp kcmvm+sDuWfAsznda5duvldVclnRUrcakpLLoYV/Lka7MrlCEVVeXYHa/IfEHkgygE2NTbNuN xK/t2h1cHfnbZw7Y32io49j7qZiwKsB/2M+c/+fx30TLBDevdsPaXvSOD2GH2b5JtzW/JDo2R HKyEhmLgmuTZn8IWv4GuQCCZhwLV0oOnEPZ6vnWOa/Hb503pPJFVu0o9JEVcBxVhCesMQiZd7 TSEPY6eDdsRH7yLo9om6WQBIPnneXZGJc98AMhGxxOwQ1ak3px31c6fwtsKSftv0oy32QN7ih 8J+HrhqXSKsfr1pU4WiArJ4IFEDkE+pJJ2bc2jYImyV5C96cfaRK8CUXkwfDdGFYD+ALLxbzC YUKhl6n/AzBc+0gIh1eRIdtaQ/Q0aK06cIuOoRQuEbkwcAsdc1rGn8oZcp+HkW/9yX2cY7t9N YBygV/GS0WkIqOjg3m2fSiPHypEAezoFX2CA/jOnIao7BP1PKI97KQ0ZBsU5tndFjKE5ijaUZ I6iHFgkEHAUImGOSACP/c0i7vwzCIryzypO2hGQW2SNn8sDPfdVIEnLDWdCJ4Insh4/08SOgz zuR9kcpLhdL2ViUkQaclnyAke7WBC6O2O0+L37VRI6vO6rUp/HR2x3Q5D8Iiyak5emZl+V/KC NejCCmng5GtiBRVhcJPxbEg8hqfcAaXrcE5Zxcn9+zi8i6srVsGbvLRJ3vnPBlOOTXK87vE1r 7RUVolRjMvGjY7LXCYXPKZDVlPzr5DCBWxYFuNmEzFYw1Y+mBBpWTRXaEoPIbmD3OvGgk/Cls YLSrjIxzgVcIixPYWXQCoIARcoq/DwjUE6+QB28zX92mNIKiElg/g4PWB/b5e15tXXQiqDFCg X7dMPWwZF/y7VvKRj8+YQ8NozxddsXvPVQi0FSkeYPcNLmKSo1NlBRw1yUahJ/Wm/OvbUVRd7 oOX4NGWo0q9cI7xXGa6HpQSRVckxQ8Efa/i72YB9Et2hivRRjpsp5O/ta2gASunqWh7fSIYeH BL+Hf5kq7eMzbXwFOAxw8ZfngR3yVHTEpPFW6H4+6X4ySf2X0XzZnMr4m4Uc0cEo36zvGlTSN 5eyKosRakoo3Uz9XzLngMCPbTN3jXP7cBBVXIvT2AAYlTZ2orUQmhks04l1HGA808sJeeQNS1 u5MrKBRvV9LS69q4Ar/TR6x+WPZQNLmOPxM1/fc9b0a7VcKr4Gvr4v45XtBQYzfUxwwjARCW9 U7XKdZEbfXbjlfTPeLJ8C9xi6py4xPUFGRyonNma7KNcgm+5iC7VfUHQ3xYOCj8NJPKX2gcvW t7w8jXTu5VQvJBY6+wMOgGaFPeM8kkQsGgnCPiSq5ymmjtJ+HCq/Ez7ZVC7AWs6tRxYmzDu/Y L7Ap7scrfQQDsgwoxyoKZc5l43uqguD8XAYGVPiGvy3TZsoNbvk7vPc6cbaa2G+vShTgZdpkh 2KmzjPwhOmQBRg1avlHCNXfxoCwlW0+fRsazRlYzPeEr0JicUcNEZ4gF8lKBYJas5aw2VfmEy rmKn+k+d96CZLOceu4VwGVH7cM7KqXT5vlQBiK+snON3ghbmicUSHKirPyFSGEGO93TrF0nx/ YiIAdnh3jgBkgfw0tr4FFuQGgyWWqU58yYQfYUx02Bi+2wE1O10eLeYi1DKsWPlQAZD4JkejJ 4mUFUx/2i5fUuoyMNB8ZVrhzWg3Mnj96MCmu7YVDYFkpRNYqYuuYjWG3WFWghX8qedZglJf5Z l0CXDJmzFJ8yfc9SbUcp7NKRL/co0F5TOF7EQbf0+aLA+udqrI9Yxs0+M4BEGO5nwgnJwc8tm djqxm30w+a5z1DJjkicUAl8+z1xFql7GA9K/pgcpeouW7dFx+8tskzNmuHOXee4qYuOBMFZG1 N/RCfi1/oapa43X6dKaNDMOXkqerSgHEKKFDAMCR3DpMtdE+XKQAxE54QTrETPORCPGXuo+Z8 QQ+SyHFA1u4UEaDWpd60ymzPsIUEoIG54M5Wcgwkk9pFU9FHgSAo/G6NQcWpQZhmmR3w8Hzxj Z0T1Mgp/JRbMhuzRGdIiSNjIB+Tvm5qHUHusm5GcmEQlv6wKG7tJl+dCsiTKR4BQbXbk3kUD7 F1Kti9rRy72BQlTzDu60AO83fnBDy7tsekCEGzrZ7b9/w37Z/3fGRrjaGGfc8mNjoreZYdhOZ l5m9gHo0wZduSTERMuG9Ue0KSnE6DGgRGucfkdubUgyD6Gj17+K7gwKj5XYySLH7E8YknJ1wU 2F7PLaRPw/R+D8n5RfxNi1Kb6gNCWPYIDi97CLSf7i+hZzAO7E4JKj7Vu3v6gEguyXwA47qZS upiE91sTwsCRA/AO2k5SrJdRydq+WKAG6/kBIMcGbYHfymX3Ox6wQRfHQS70NrzLI1XovXFsX aGNK8VZP8w8myC5LxUXiW9VP1qgIN1TSjdlw6w6MtS4M6m4gMmsaCG7UKAotT46iGVQ2Nw2M+ cCRN2dVZFqTy0QbBpOKm2LjNkdS9/S/Q9LfMAK56tqRylQdduEsDxhZXmkKJzUxZcvxPIuPcD HggL57rnAHQubz9dxCL23S3pK8gQ7pIPf3fbBxYCB2Gxn5kB0CjKIDDus3BPhYPF5a90Fb248 brB23tmG7jLBzf2pK1T0RI0u91rFlKOnPNnQlLn06nZrXf4VQaAjAttlx0OyNi3ZA5za7RNx5 UK0qMdvH6fnNil6f4a0DqljCJv0TKJwD8NzeD0vR3YU+LSrQBUscu9axM64P5VHQTAgE7qZjR M2fjjdvWH+Stdvh7vGF+Kw85wZy6WxtM0Z0UCKdtHx+Qgrg52gmrTabZbEEopNyWMGPIgEdpt ldXLMdk35ojsHBkr8xZGq1UT41MJKfOSxkmd+yDKiapLealb0C+GFL43pFQwWS9MgFm/v/k7y mjXH4dBei1bieU/uCVTuR599b06sQRzQKfi3VTWmDsc8AUUR0t9yCAXG61SPElSsucnMqQkIB yu49+sxsRYTMl97Q7RcOejwG/1WFQwWJ8o9I9wPz+FIbPCfsS+ndD6qpJNsxAdeQBH9yks474 XkpV67y0ZSlyXi3cCn+Wwop5jVlVtpUsK7h9tZtlXnI2yXkVfZ7nPKYuHtsbr1OTH+dBQJ3jS eva31HveQy0AytgmLx57pQU/DwQcoDNEeueHrL22X3/0a0zpIPxBGga0+4rQo67pSL4rFggyM 8KJvaIVs1ncO12DLWoNCpKsrGvD+IRsTMJCN7WroIZPJCBlZHEShmzu6vMlyYvIeDtNGwt0v6 34dy4whJ3NVf17QzlFgqqD5IGbTcsb3A2ibOonH4MSpUElpbuOCeT4fAB92CouZvQ3J0Klyd6 ALzPJjt1bdAsfLZjdDRCNCXtPMCpW/yTFxN+UUBkum1/hHNBGIqKz3pt7DpwQCPleRgRjlIQO INV0/VKmwrT6Vu8I2bWwaBPpKGWNoCvPEGxSoKCSL6tyvI2z9KNuABsb3ApXjUtJYSt77ndw0 +3XJTV2cqzEjgbBfFQ0taKv85NOTf2IMSLRXTYyZHqlhLs+uUa/N25LRqTEgKNdZDkk/2h9TC 7RsxuJXUbBDEXMI7TNcA/YbfYeKFOVXU3NPlS00IAiTMy2ZNSYoOH/q/gwNshcth/HCPI5Y2a wDSLV6q1Mh/L5t1CdNTnXvECUjNevXmzvg6RyMQtUVl1Q24L1WQHJkmpdL2HcDV1ZZ1u16cYX DX+4bdvcCU0UYf9kUKh621QfOvW7v4oGPWuPQ9/93t4Jkr7g4HXwbN6DT/2GPrcdhnBTd9/xX vmXzImbEclb2lBcPQsaeoLZxAkHy2HdsShhi9l6OCzZVGOfxqXWFO+iViiLiItjDQZb8mEoJX tkBoXKx3f0+sb2KqPVr55ywLdWOF0rI6uMaZE5NQbENspoOQv/+qYLMcn5403BQ/owFpCp1FK sgCZQliUYtUzsD82bWqcMKUJ63Wh3iyfne5W5T3qcB7edQxmTK/E9sW658JVwh1F3Qpcu/tmR rJWBCEYiNucQqrisdVQm2Ag/CTSDcfrdkvP/KfpF3usNWH81wPEZXGZSPCHzj+/WuVlrs/Qq0 uOatqUqI4qNKBDwgcesoGwjhs2FNVWK5/DYVwPSpGOav+9SHBSxhCYtF8gJqizeg7htFjxrS8 Pzekijkx8STP6QWHesyK+c1IVFddvXnyuCZ6rfhCF+pfwkZTGdHv0xXIvLerSOXLDOW5HTzic Be4uOwkM7f1q9uFoRMek4I01LPV3yqJdcuNv6YOvXeDc6NafjtwGzVYNF6UdAH3suof5J9+Rp OqJkFvxuDCcaLEvSFqjImn3iK0ddvyTqxDURqpbMiOvad/+RjXmCo520fmVdhUj4pK/RpjMS9 LXbXcbWJDWHIhrbbr6X3qhc+iPEz98TrHIH8hIiB3yFsv+TjdmXySiCIlj6z0Eu153nZHoK0j ue/v72Ki//JZwL3TodBcAH6OU2hX9N0hpW25Dv+OYtbbA3x3RpZRN5MLJjsHlOhdyHXu8aC4W FAvn8CUjKD6n4DgdNDg/ygwDZvX2/Z1Ue8BEjtZi7CEwRFE/e4Hy52XtLPOm/csK+GZ6lfXdn xzBp84VEg/i6BDSrxgvm9KMVic6CR/g1x3wW0i9HD76s0fGmemQDKSD5jDNpYtEfCdKDM27vY AwhZDSGqRthVD8j+HQ3l/nziQ1hMH50AWR5wUKBdSGmTKiGNDt8f0ll8Z7SeD3RDzrxy6h9qR Z6DkrS6z6kXS+qvoiAB+IxlRPMq1LLTI31bA5zs8oKGWm4tvyKRa1fS/dnHY283t8l3lB+P7v q/ajAflbM94R2Re3j2NY0J/pvBZJgfRZtqy7ILpw/cy+LilIbcVyfCTq1H2WwQ6SkZX5mKrw5 7Gx/c5hPyWC2cN5m2kq4jiLwdulM1qgsKV13wTh1tbZ4MQZoqNGCE5TTUOjpvUHV1ODVfxcmm ZLFse2BXOyKpVq0R1gMIUQ/s9bc3fBYWZsjCqnQvtiLlgm+f5gwmDVR/G/Mny2fOlQvOFEPMt ngBL9xEiQMHmPBu5DTWyUuDX1qzRnyMOF21/zUTdTr7XwfPwMEq6T8bJvEznsxxMGb/4SMU8a m+qM//CWISGbdx7qh3WnYv3hnZIPgKupY2DFQV/eOXyCewGNP/rUW1aUphIle0YO57ndWtkyq R7+MsAGjAZQe4lKNN46JGUqarwXX7VcrH0HQherZYuQhhvWmyWjEHm1YBpzKJn9ija9YBm4BM lXmwHjlhKl5VVTZVn+HlwyxbgDtly3hHFGZdq3vI3JjVKuesy1PPLsJ5NBzmKq9Sl7sITa17v +X4/1SVbuRgvhma0YFmDZLe0/xMz0ub8sBTWeCptQIL3dIM8Xf7OQm0CicSdzmkeSMDityk/c GhbBWYcF5/x8v0g53aORPJSuo1EBRC8HmWsNHbAEcT7YvHReEXkOk/4ACuecUc7qq5OWCmO8P bXmWXef1ruggBIQXpCIL9fWYoGq8FIKjnjxyed2FBgydBuejSsp5fBlKDLUzloJ2lQp2J8bOU b1BFObh7z7OGO5QkMdFtEiYymFAp7VJDb8qmSk0AYAjlyDkG9k9CRJiWL4VRRXJLQL2Ot9GyD 1yXUCbG21BSKba4/w6uCaarpgW1+Adt5JLtgWN1ljCxuwgln0bb6p5IKAQOhSKOv8zobCBaEa c5lNhcm+wLXph38bKJS4e37Z5eLYjjMUBIYALwNMicLgyUwrHU//Obg6NmV6BBjXKnzZgQV/8 x5yk22Y116nGhUydoNYe/dCPsB5akm731jQkNlo/H9Q6l2nWp5nYaY7hkaaMrFGg+pwQFg2tw lZeqsjtXTjexdBNP/dnmIb2PFm3CiQZU8DfDnW3WfX1EWc8oDZw7zRqv2MXceDUU7zTjy408Z hsCWzcHYwrgkEndtVQyBQYsC6KlqufwBwI6sr3QjR5JRQFLMvR6PtIGFlTC3s6nOfoLE5vzf7 kCp7gv23XD4TdFzYnUucXVygEwi+PDxwUwrX1b8g1x0+V3UdKApyx6tsy2/T+gUqUGqgx99+z LS+stiaE1gUNmg6VaGWeTMVS5rHx46neGokIk7+Ep8eEeQHHJBWrphDdAzozfAYpzrANAFISM iW9UHqwGvOJu099eX8qEtfMYN0oXU6W36SN0zaMwNE7dDxblP7AESXbu5pzhiThxNqOwCWyl+ wY+5qedl9z9RF30cuffIU6ooKlLRrjApwXSrMYN6rmojWcpMzl9c9yoakaY7XFiiBAuLVzxSx 6ObFdmAm0NfiuHstGVuPo2MYY/Kbm9JWBqK0oA6Jen5LIfxdNWFUcieGCVmdoFUwVCnUFXKGB cFqPY3Yyf5fjHzia1tRQ9lrWMMpnj1qp50O9nagdLWW8iAcaoZgAaKqIO2hc2eas0sgGFTGBV EZ0Ruor18PHu/A4wxUPVQIyi8actd3N4VWhFmMAjXrEipWr2bwPsNFg6W4q65L1hlRcDWgAP/ dCzCxTstdeAAtQejQ4CU= On Sun, 2026-11-01 at 22:37 +0800, Chengfeng Lin wrote: >=20 > Is this the path you had in mind, or were you referring to a different > update? I'd be happy to test another candidate change. Where I see negative impact of the __dequeue_task() update is when probe components compete in one cgroup, ie pinned wakelat and 8 pinned hogs used to measure the delta between smp and concur CPU distribution modes during cgroup vs cgroup testing, all stuffed into one cgroup. Do whatever you like there, just keep update_curr() far away from cfs_rq_of(se) and probe goes silent. For virgin flat in isolation, that was the only signal the probe generated. -Mike