From mboxrd@z Thu Jan 1 00:00:00 1970 Received: from mout.web.de (mout.web.de [212.227.15.4]) (using TLSv1.2 with cipher ECDHE-RSA-AES256-GCM-SHA384 (256/256 bits)) (No client certificate requested) by smtp.subspace.kernel.org (Postfix) with ESMTPS id F350925A631 for ; Tue, 19 Aug 2025 09:16:33 +0000 (UTC) Authentication-Results: smtp.subspace.kernel.org; arc=none smtp.client-ip=212.227.15.4 ARC-Seal:i=1; a=rsa-sha256; d=subspace.kernel.org; s=arc-20240116; t=1755594996; cv=none; b=QEvjVBr0LYFVIAJIIEveq4BiianI8guA9VEQAQT8qv4aa9LxOnVc1rVjbX2Uyy/AzR9PuHTwHNf4jWp/8I2Nqcnq6fTMTgkRwaVtzbb4WHa5DohvlYA6zICcDboQzvxPo3N4kfvBZ0uqI0FMOZ8WQsK+WdlzU1TgYawK5IS6+/U= ARC-Message-Signature:i=1; a=rsa-sha256; d=subspace.kernel.org; s=arc-20240116; t=1755594996; c=relaxed/simple; bh=eBYVJ2FkORuTwqWvVkBmCDP8mHAzlrBhN4QFixSH68M=; h=Message-ID:Date:MIME-Version:To:Cc:References:Subject:From: In-Reply-To:Content-Type; b=oJ2yVHRGoVVlfc0O7uuWhPMKZ2n3NTtUR/BdqpsK+0wIobcfiMEtxCEWKj5SSSP0dMQbBCHN9wDqzbiDr/mwJsbsNbr13DWYcQC3+ZX/9aerUFKdVkoAru6YOldxi+aLPF8pIoOQVzWH+WSZKmKtimIJHJ1j73HXt741p3K7XFg= ARC-Authentication-Results:i=1; smtp.subspace.kernel.org; dmarc=pass (p=quarantine dis=none) header.from=web.de; spf=pass smtp.mailfrom=web.de; dkim=pass (2048-bit key) header.d=web.de header.i=markus.elfring@web.de header.b=kdpflB0T; arc=none smtp.client-ip=212.227.15.4 Authentication-Results: smtp.subspace.kernel.org; dmarc=pass (p=quarantine dis=none) header.from=web.de Authentication-Results: smtp.subspace.kernel.org; spf=pass smtp.mailfrom=web.de Authentication-Results: smtp.subspace.kernel.org; dkim=pass (2048-bit key) header.d=web.de header.i=markus.elfring@web.de header.b="kdpflB0T" DKIM-Signature: v=1; a=rsa-sha256; c=relaxed/relaxed; d=web.de; s=s29768273; t=1755594972; x=1756199772; i=markus.elfring@web.de; bh=eBYVJ2FkORuTwqWvVkBmCDP8mHAzlrBhN4QFixSH68M=; h=X-UI-Sender-Class:Message-ID:Date:MIME-Version:To:Cc:References: Subject:From:In-Reply-To:Content-Type:Content-Transfer-Encoding: cc:content-transfer-encoding:content-type:date:from:message-id: mime-version:reply-to:subject:to; b=kdpflB0TjkM4sUfl5fIKS6zpNPXrY4PrtLO5iZNIZMatMzpjY/OBIuodfg3Hc5ud QldIwpDodqEv6xmyU7P5qtkwIlcBEKuoE31MdZtZlvpWdb84VA//2WULjEJPUf5ba GXbq+pqCkizeqdBFx+NK1OqLpidEYIVJlvG3N9BXHq2EMAoMfnnIwK/HCsGEtcxS6 C9mGx5ZVH6RSuR+9Pn1Dp2QGMLDXa6jYuEcEr8D2z6P6TbNH7p6I8EQ9UjSMUvN0z toqqzLyvxNBNIkuGZqisiLtEhewIPrPmx0Yv6+MODHBQSr9iRcobW2k/UE+gFt/L/ C24oriShYd3E2sESeA== X-UI-Sender-Class: 814a7b36-bfc1-4dae-8640-3722d8ec6cd6 Received: from [192.168.178.29] ([94.31.69.248]) by smtp.web.de (mrweb005 [213.165.67.108]) with ESMTPSA (Nemesis) id 1MSIF2-1uzGnU1shk-00Uyrc; Tue, 19 Aug 2025 11:16:12 +0200 Message-ID: <88fd2a23-ecdb-47ec-9328-62b9bda7bff4@web.de> Date: Tue, 19 Aug 2025 11:16:11 +0200 Precedence: bulk X-Mailing-List: linux-kernel@vger.kernel.org List-Id: List-Subscribe: List-Unsubscribe: MIME-Version: 1.0 User-Agent: Mozilla Thunderbird To: Liao Yuanhong , jfs-discussion@lists.sourceforge.net, Dave Kleikamp Cc: LKML References: <20250819032816.426276-1-liaoyuanhong@vivo.com> Subject: Re: [PATCH] JFS: Remove redundant 0 value initialization Content-Language: en-GB, de-DE From: Markus Elfring In-Reply-To: <20250819032816.426276-1-liaoyuanhong@vivo.com> Content-Type: text/plain; charset=UTF-8 Content-Transfer-Encoding: 7bit X-Provags-ID: V03:K1:EN4AWiQJyFq1Sucoj9nMHzU1fSTvsh2ltNimcq0EnQBzor0dk5h y4X9SEyLDjI/H8lujokVCeIp9dmpTod8/YnHFI1F3sxzTs1Q0aRaqMhOc41SvOB2aHnYdI1 f4PuWPq3Aybcw83/c3ljizEQRhbqqDiXhNy5mq2vrj0csubb5nhLiZU1cGMuR/FdBLa6GER BTXmkqMRjcs6NUV/vWLwA== X-Spam-Flag: NO UI-OutboundReport: notjunk:1;M01:P0:EGSQzH2KABU=;1rBwsA1O/UvaT/wMNkcwmjeZ1qI b6UTwumo/8WT2coQ49d4kVZyWQAVF5UAC8+xKDc/nQskNrPbnbqavUkSEIMy3DRPRo6zLWsd0 X5YmFnXzWmaexMUrFbRVbT0zrWpXJHEBsjEUQ75UuSqwIehKjrk0ogAFzvL6snEiFglvXDIc/ gN9x2MM1YQfpwIC/dkgXHHUsjRO1zd6FwQLPD2zx9dxCmfVFFPjABroh7fCxQx3i8lJL1/b3V BO7MSm59bTNRJVuGiA4rMLbY2SoT0RRqze+qTMMvWeUJz8/DeW+NYa1u6sr59kkqosL+/3z8a HG/yfWcoi9aIs/HszmIQsBpymWTFWF1fGZLj8Ajj9TvEogzNAutsFdutydI/62iYfWIyCwO6f WwvzqIH2Sm29UXSMApDE4cJ9qbC/0HIapqHBSrfP6vpdV6DvRYI/HJVjo+OORaSbUxXX7SrdI GMt6HuM1q1MAe8ZxnFDWvD0nnYV9spc6An/Ppe1o4apvxWyNkFLCj//vZCcKcY54b2U+ul4IJ BdFEIIfVSrUkxp57PlbRwD72zmKNb/rtKvi1UchlM2vb1Pu+RW9wbHR1wIpqmJgqGwPLu+bAP g8UFqyYSFcDXmZabnVvUZjQjOaJ/CEFPuwGoh5ujR8QujQ7otTXr6+yjCopfAUHOOCcnX68sp IO3uJ2kksL+u1xCPpG5CRre1bw+bkffNv2xe1KnYZ4G2ls5Vf/+y+YiD4luoBPhODCjIpWJnQ TiwXEIj0Wwf6AEgjQ9ySuo90Prm/qkvAvcBMlhIW5VVW3N91CPO2liAIiAIOScUsSHu9XgRHo WCfUKjUPhZfiZfW+kPNc9p9bmRtqqbcEpswiwf6NgBcs5qHjNptqznhU1JNW+YNC+TlyArQb6 hzp62/vm6AOtpw0Tj98vhOcu0n+t3717C2FU/wIr2woiI8oNsbQ5Y2fLroM36Yaod31tl0EKP U2XyO26dgTZbYhQQgrH4vpi7uLDggFkVHIIwBZnnlSQhnPcgJHWlsWAD3ai+6PczmzgunwyKw wBJkJ9CkGl8uKNsvjb9Zv1Cx0csiIUiiW1b52F329hXhzUoQJJ6LQuy/2PT/wM19bcpHFaTLy eij+BmxkVnsH40hA1D9HZF/uv0SHX3xf2R3qpnPuDkWWlqtRWfzdLfGxBw/bOZic9TW8q1pwT 99fXRFYLvKVVXV3rr7W5UenqZR9lgCkJLC5rOSf5YFKjkgtl3UH4RUp7Kavp1vKeGuph54uxX Y6MchL7Y9KWftnihFUfmq3OVJih0F06hKSDkvY/vJsW5VfSr8xGQU38PpaKpfo3XBG1YjXGLm qvWP0G69qmF8E7qHBJdt0GsuZ3GtsxR1Kg3/1McDwQyoSeo6/LVXmUUxDNAVZk0hYzHnpwpXJ U37C1c9A1EHuyyEbZdMLzb/NxcDrEjyrEo8k5yESR/zew5cmINaYsm0d9Fo1w3A4A07/Sy731 x4ca9DRW49MDGsHDLaP1dlzo8BpXCB5lQMbypI62QrupaZSEfQAXmRLhCcDjBgsmve0s5fsq4 6EeiTCVn2H/atb/B6+fjTHaZFlXH+HhgPNoQH+PO0jf1NXv7MOSpc62Mmz/yYj6o0z5HHQumh ISxdHOrZqJlpR7BjTm9c9v6+GES2koynfDRwKN8BiuNxvGm5G/psJ+ZihKPzXy5LjHivR+3GI eHVw47kOMrGHzIPiBI4/mP42Q1Fys4lljkH55ZT8nz8f+5oU6jpgbIVvuWE9+0gnaR4i8IuIl RXFbwdV1hXUVonZ1pFR477nCyJhVuF/MUoyECC2ck+w98dIoiu1aY+YrTbuosH8+5V1+n7qKe GFuWV3pfYQwN+0zs5BIv8gyxJ6+hFo4KGzSRY+MzCGwcFX8udzladDll60+rnNQ2g8zM37YO4 fFCgaCny/+08pLCv1iyzA/8GQ9jPRfyo/sOaLnjIiZhFqrZVdLVqCHKhSqFL0wh9Zc/+PJxSx 1hPEbqOktwgnyYKz/3FXlG0LIIpx2MxqtU775WsawdvmIvA2JyvBnV5HpUiBuP3OBGkBPUi9M /SdddteEypFpeYW3WMxYjNxMItnv7VA2usg4AZnjCGP+/EQA+H3Yuv3EjiOeitTH+110SBx7V /KFARss4nw1ybqCS0ABZ1WULmto+F7YH3JXcnO5Z4OjREXwNewcpHXAp0Om+GAW28csabnvxm 0lYeVWJ7TSs2dkRqQYgo71d+MsJZtZt9PFkFbNrNOA+e7PZGj/4+NH69RKcYzrQAGqF3RAo64 IjN5nY1OKoe1vRxLxMQXQ7otkc4BXQO1XidDKiPukN9QRhVEe+ZK8JFX4K++QeFDeJI2lIHaw sjsUp4CE6Db7+eIfbvsSY5zxpgouekuqA/4ombAs+Y5jdPfZ79yvVqdTXRxyxcUtAeiXhpSY1 PdVUCmwsY26/VtPKOAVMa1dWfNPhhCp0WuP2VXC0ZhAffpoj5Vm6762SU4XT1HsELWaoYOhqb CTaWGrtqXk0HWZxQMdtT96TBo/3z+QbBNC7BgOL1bNPfFF9rcdIt5XGR3F+hcoz/0S/uroqpu 97ZlFIOtxXnAZl78P4TaVn02pNVobtYOpzSDA/UwiA5b0kLywsWQuzZkCNwBd0B2hDvj0y9cL FJHiAChXSpMwRObURjZxR/n4drJpN8awo9nONeM9T+8EDJ74CFIGrohzrqUTe3EyVhzTVpHtj YH3NBex9xxTaq9U/HLjOEfw3ebPcbKG2kEQu5Kgj0TnDquTd4m+prnX5kTWAKO5mNtO2Clsrs YK/cr8R48+4xzkW1IuFpOOxsWfjXSqq1NUoencsEnWjEXhK8RdlXbgUDXwWpcvQmEiBDoterp ZPorIR7naZrpfR/QBoGVGKsBRvyWStWarMfsmTdkldVkcYxH+O7NU68TszeMtPiU3prGOUUpB lxSH0/CfNPvHJpN1iFyv/dxoc6HlrbrgagB8+TJ3VaV7fJsx4JOKPup8vKf9olhDe4D7fyu6z UN6itpKHmxSBlBrOXpCP4drUdi5e+vlqeu0eEPxC/Kv1vVbkwWSRbG0+rSb+/3pKUuFLzb5JV 7R+T0w+YaGAFIJS4Wd6MWvt4RQZLua/IOj/Eztka1rl5K4/ZpLCLzU5w4xh6fyNJKiCt6ZTlg qdbPYYhTRjbogDiHYwfBabUkit6U7hruZJaGItUqqT/ZfhQqjRTAziHMqAg28ehlJeD3nEvRc aKtblWeqmKeMO/9u8N6PF8ZIytXLLrH0SwowCD9HW2LcqC4xGZdywOMJG9b/iFH7nLIYUw8hC eCkUdGG/Hl9MrGylvyxJnexr9O2bFsPMm4Y2K8qPrOe6Oy+8MKk6Ub/Tq/mumM+CBEmzJtN4Z jZjJedf3uWZ3cqoWWKFp5u2E8c9IGfd0ZLQwBp6xj/MVPpIFDXqymWAgkTwQinKz/2W1tstoG 4rIU//LATN+EKXzZZZlblHEqmJvBAT5/jq471w70EyDHRE3dYi+Lodo3XtirmHvlvOd3nndbB biQqzfALo1vukLoUrelKSfg8+v4b4OE7K9k/PDu4ySMlTMnq8/GVL3t7qEbYKoCQtPdrzuiSn hygwXYnmtLlFAOy0pVLhkqUa0iqB1uDI3hrD1yPXk/H3goxFpcIqjejdl38skOtPg2is7UuHi vbn2XIOsV/nZ5AGpNhPv2kXGlJjvlJtnZw/rYDJvhwLWqicFVZCcwptDqLFG7KBP25YnTaw1L EU2o0cPlmzh4CwZZS6cXj7xP5oD5dWaJofp8Eg6RlKEubP9ako/ykorxxRV/shqrA8/3QZYAy SqqcyYYdj6VOHDGjh5o4tZXunaQn9nT4aQylhkDUAdyL+SGFn8tPCgPlyeWLfgVeoyDvQ0Gk2 eQHBB2mOBeUI+2/NL2ANijGgzjKiAwFYFwjCPa++rsecQqFFntiBLDSxg0ov4D000+rll07MM 23GqtwCVRO6NT0dzqJSCuH8IsR5kdngq1wi3L2R53u5hamcVvl6NT106lkRTRNQrkwudKn1LW M78RfbjDO0c1W3Qf6DDSbZ2SBLX/QSKICFUeAgq/8jFUMRw77w+cWILcas8DJVzPtluAnyQSj EzESVm9ST0yjVFO74AO3RkKxzk8v/8i2umfEc8mRm7jdxRBgjlmgreaCiH/JzwQuCeimm021P own3U/HCrHSsIz2YC9r20yPxpvfz/iQbPtsJvnskTHQ92p2rYxxrHoPBUrog1r4ItdlTsXl9z mVNAau8/hFcHj8bEqtglx3ct0SPVQ4LfpyQ3tZI3lb1rL12DOfDdsqR6NjUlFQ/F7zUhyCcFA A8ax01/siygDBzkVH3YF43IRIwlf0CGgmbkh0qcrgKavjPRZ2ASgvYVB/nKH9Ymg85kZOB845 Iyfj37pBH+TRdO+trXTuT+YRAcuadM8UuIKlmqFmW34ps39YME/pHGelAwFPL66I/hk3WXBEb iiIPgdH4IfeGTjniqYoYcS5n1NZ92WxPgnY5PkpXnpQQ8IutMD71W/BDDhGYcByyJWkIWCPzi izX7Nykmmd4RgCv92p40mt4Jt2gWUjEw/7AmDj4S3gFdgnwuoACS1P46kvFIv5EVqfVH3vRWS 47rgS7+n6ghESHR23hutzHpsQpxMDaSc4CqA39gMt9+WO0a9v1L0QohJTRZafqMIjf1w== > The jfs_log struct is already zeroed by kzalloc(). It's redundant to > initialize dummy_log->base to 0. See also once more: https://git.kernel.org/pub/scm/linux/kernel/git/torvalds/linux.git/tree/Documentation/process/submitting-patches.rst?h=v6.17-rc2#n94 Regards, Markus