Re: [PATCH] printk: Fix _DESCS_COUNT type for 64-bit systems

[Petr Mladek <pmladek@suse.com>]

On Mon 2026-02-02 17:41:40, feng.zhou wrote:
> The _DESCS_COUNT macro currently uses 1U (32-bit unsigned) instead of
> 1UL (unsigned long), which breaks the intended overflow testing design
> on 64-bit systems.
> 
> Problem Analysis:
> ----------------
> The printk_ringbuffer uses a deliberate design choice to initialize
> descriptor IDs near the maximum 62-bit value to trigger overflow early
> in the system's lifetime. This is documented in printk_ringbuffer.h:
> 
>   "initial values are chosen that map to the correct initial array
>    indexes, but will result in overflows soon."
> 
> The DESC0_ID macro calculates:
>   DESC0_ID(ct_bits) = DESC_ID(-(_DESCS_COUNT(ct_bits) + 1))
> 
> On 64-bit systems with typical configuration (descbits=16):
> - Current buggy behavior: DESC0_ID = 0xfffeffff
> - Expected behavior:      DESC0_ID = 0x3ffffffffffeffff
> 
> The buggy version only uses 32 bits, which means:
> 1. The initial ID is nowhere near 2^62
> 2. It would take ~140 trillion wraps to trigger 62-bit overflow
> 3. The overflow handling code is never tested in practice
> 
> Root Cause:
> ----------
> The issue is in this line:
>   #define _DESCS_COUNT(ct_bits)    (1U << (ct_bits))
> 
> When _DESCS_COUNT(16) is calculated:
>   1U << 16 = 0x10000 (32-bit value)
>   -(0x10000 + 1) = -0x10001 = 0xFFFEFFFF (32-bit two's complement)
> 
> On 64-bit systems, this 32-bit value doesn't get extended to create
> the intended 62-bit ID near the maximum value.
> 
> Impact:
> ------
> While index calculations still work correctly in the short term, this
> bug has several implications:
> 
> 1. Violates the design intention documented in the code
> 2. Overflow handling code paths remain untested
> 3. ABA detection code doesn't get exercised under overflow conditions
> 4. In extreme long-term running scenarios (though unlikely), could
>    potentially cause issues when ID actually reaches 2^62
> 
> Verification:
> ------------
> Tested on ARM64 system with CONFIG_LOG_BUF_SHIFT=20 (descbits=15):
> - Before fix: DESC0_ID(16) = 0xfffeffff
> - After fix:  DESC0_ID(16) = 0x3fffffffffff7fff
> 
> The fix aligns _DESCS_COUNT with _DATA_SIZE, which already correctly
> uses 1UL:
>   #define _DATA_SIZE(sz_bits)    (1UL << (sz_bits))
> 
> Signed-off-by: feng.zhou <realsummitzhou@gmail.com>

JFYI, the patch has been committed into printk/linux.git,
branch rework/prb-fixes.

Best Regards,
Petr