From mboxrd@z Thu Jan 1 00:00:00 1970 Received: from mout.gmx.net (mout.gmx.net [212.227.17.21]) (using TLSv1.2 with cipher ECDHE-RSA-AES256-GCM-SHA384 (256/256 bits)) (No client certificate requested) by smtp.subspace.kernel.org (Postfix) with ESMTPS id 7E4C5566C5B; Tue, 29 Sep 2026 19:49:28 +0000 (UTC) Authentication-Results: smtp.subspace.kernel.org; arc=none smtp.client-ip=212.227.17.21 ARC-Seal:i=1; a=rsa-sha256; d=subspace.kernel.org; s=arc-20240116; t=1790711370; cv=none; b=lIQbdnzmkvmg3aDV1JSM1nIzvVgTFRyq+gwkuh0Bax93/VRLK+3+pZL3cc+Ktle+ZV68S/ZYgF3QrMJprjLlnFxebVQYoDQrqrEOtfoo6ZoskMc5/pH6kcATGvHM/YATrvjdL9V7zMCtwQNZOb7NUADF8/8bRiOfzp4o1B+knpE= ARC-Message-Signature:i=1; a=rsa-sha256; d=subspace.kernel.org; s=arc-20240116; t=1790711370; c=relaxed/simple; bh=p/pSnik6qfJ3BXcVmRlbnkpfz25VONWPN9lTOmL/LUo=; h=Date:From:To:Cc:Subject:Message-ID:References:MIME-Version: Content-Type:Content-Disposition:In-Reply-To; b=N4cXXwR9MrlcbPzxSdLSy50TcxBvuglcRhG75RoX0te30gbwSh/ivcjPJ2UPcELn8Jyp8UIMxDYr2tVzuAjp90kndgRYikfLWgKPONTK5xzBpg6VDMI2mT2iU5OMellSGiMoXtHA8C1catFlUliKC8GzXJoxhxBe+9gEkAaQr2o= ARC-Authentication-Results:i=1; smtp.subspace.kernel.org; dmarc=pass (p=quarantine dis=none) header.from=gmx.li; spf=pass smtp.mailfrom=gmx.li; dkim=pass (2048-bit key) header.d=gmx.li header.i=arc@gmx.li header.b=Vy9rrSy8; arc=none smtp.client-ip=212.227.17.21 Authentication-Results: smtp.subspace.kernel.org; dmarc=pass (p=quarantine dis=none) header.from=gmx.li Authentication-Results: smtp.subspace.kernel.org; spf=pass smtp.mailfrom=gmx.li Authentication-Results: smtp.subspace.kernel.org; dkim=pass (2048-bit key) header.d=gmx.li header.i=arc@gmx.li header.b="Vy9rrSy8" DKIM-Signature: v=1; a=rsa-sha256; c=relaxed/relaxed; d=gmx.li; s=s31663417; t=1790711342; x=1791316142; i=arc@gmx.li; bh=kv00LVWtdFcko4iXwZSVIy395iy1ATgYZFMp7dtzNyE=; h=X-UI-Sender-Class:Date:From:To:Cc:Subject:Message-ID:References: MIME-Version:Content-Type:In-Reply-To:Content-Transfer-Encoding: cc:content-transfer-encoding:content-type:date:from:message-id: mime-version:reply-to:subject:to; b=Vy9rrSy8bZoIkqNLsCV+OZkmzv4iNNDPDN7G84Kkuy7mN6h4oGjYXYE+QiOmkp9T 84WoMjqiMQILgfpEb17o8NVp3ZjnOwb71v07SQZOZPFLXeI6hjTy2kpPMOb2erHp/ /WuihutbENNnb6v+lkgqZgo4FRkB/AkY8QJDD1dy6WhBvbBs+yTTMCbp3/0WVBFeN QEKZ4rTWEwC+IuxhkD8vHnx9nafo+tmUITwIPS74VoEDdFLkpcLGa+NABqWqGZ+VP sNMre1y9QpBL9+aPv+sgswZppqgu+b/lSVbtJbQ92L2Vg1KZBEeqMj0sJwUEzdobQ QQZwtTUIfBej310ytQ== X-UI-Sender-Class: 724b4f7f-cbec-4199-ad4e-598c01a50d3a Received: from client.hidden.invalid by mail.gmx.net (mrgmx105 [212.227.17.168]) with ESMTPSA (Nemesis) id 1MKbkC-1xQ0uI0SvE-00Rxc4; Tue, 29 Sep 2026 21:49:02 +0200 Date: Tue, 29 Sep 2026 21:49:03 +0200 From: Christian Ruppert To: Takashi Iwai Cc: Jaroslav Kysela , Takashi Iwai , linux-kernel@vger.kernel.org, linux-sound@vger.kernel.org, Will Porter , Peter Drabik , Neil Andrews Subject: Re: [PATCH 0/3] Add Audient EVO4 support Message-ID: References: <20260919151840.24371-1-arc@gmx.li> <87bj9g19d6.wl-tiwai@suse.de> Precedence: bulk X-Mailing-List: linux-kernel@vger.kernel.org List-Id: List-Subscribe: List-Unsubscribe: MIME-Version: 1.0 Content-Type: text/plain; charset=us-ascii Content-Disposition: inline In-Reply-To: <87bj9g19d6.wl-tiwai@suse.de> X-Provags-ID: V03:K1:78bD2x+ifZLUXWuvn8hDJB0W0JN27LaVAgN7rtJfnHoo5CCb8Oo ARYYpb0zi0wNw41olEGjhFwFQ1cTgpZh9RDtY56KfKXRdAvKgHIu96G3EHPJJIIe7fdBzgX szZRxjS7/RtYcDF9VG/A/ZhuFoMVpJ5tSBReMq9HPx3VV6d9/rYwztR2z3JXrrlZ6KQupIE b2Nb5EmjjyTyUkRN9R8DA== X-Spam-Flag: NO UI-OutboundReport: notjunk:1;M01:P0:j5TVsGa51PA=;ax52b4X/U1vlGkPfZx9A7kueite WKp5B2eMrzAn+KOxOFRRM2nMDxJJVCTeinvcX4fNwFQYMKVfhQWrHZ46xEtSpDcq7KoD5ItYb dwSxfV47TVAY76dKwfrg7yw08PJL3wjPldPohJyDarVQ1mrAHP6290TSjwK1i+diEy637HFCi 1uIsxvLtwZdBar3fN+vZCE5EZvqLVcl7x7mha04HCVnDnwYSBrrlziLYQJpWTKbJk4mGAT0aG /fXE3yvjKzJYyCi89iXgsg+m42k0kb+e7VwXiydSWLVFw9QRZhERRIixhuIG9RhW+zgq2aW5M Zeg8qScNOcRNuN2iQRiRmJj2ws5AqlOkA44OZ6V1AuiWsoIdpEygUfwTrr4AM+6cVJJ282553 6EH+mtdhlt285albS5QUgVWw+bgOgljbCWiTqBJYFar6nIWWXpqD7JP+XD359IA76cUo2kXsA D8ZUyqEqFnZ+lIE0RB1sjVULBwgVAKbGl8dxITRMpmazHZzC1bff05R3l6AIrL+nAdnHjrWqd icqNALbcxa5O5H8/nJ88vzKrglkqTg79jvsGDTKLyLdTAQBYh3msbkKitudEjlIArUNtbHxbN 46SLwauZMLIEX4lGvRla9xEK93VbtKHMtwYh/0hkKc3HYrrdjA5jcgpEz81Oi7PK5mz7ifTr8 p+miDiTirAVEcXb4NsraveY/s8u7MsYwbIm+KYkqjr8fMW3hou6gkyX3ZRq3BqHURP0+5ZV7k yLBat0OWmTx0QdtvOKzYEqtoOqy6nfhXZd6+R4w3rsNkOesH9XxwTaYfgprUv4/PG54pcOsg2 LWpL+3bYupVqyN5TBj+fy3GMsc7v/7IJpExlbdzCnOfr9Y1qPSZYL3nLvxt0sRp6uWiwm6eU3 lNfNTODafeRxwBcnl6XMMAyiUqKH6dAW4kWRuCzyHKjJ3VclgdXGz9Xc/wUZO4wK6OBhL9xvm lq1wz/+P0bxjvY12hJZLFJ9ZPgMOtDCsdRZxdJL3FaFvE9wg5U0mjqL6I8c0vObJVOUc+4ydf tjLLFONCrUU7KGj3m88//C999ndqbJ3g7eSEEDFhY1RrUNLipwOm+qoP0PtkUUvohbf5VPYPH I78zQbtgWTholgjVZq+7FG4C0albJMadoin12khJWbA/VNMt6Mu8Flt+7RxA/orEcQcOezzDs OQ5K/Q2VGwuOZxOan4cCyFDqn/1B8mJ3lQ45DDqopgVZP29tc5BRQO1sf2w9k+VeGeMKvVaY+ O98DqZNAi4Qg81et6h3XYJRQkVUXw5Ufhwlpe/DIeLyf01QJjvV43enEZSjwAC/lEt9girOeI EdEbRCC5O6C4MWMRwNxHWRo9A7hPgVGGtXZIwWnMw3blY++JYlymcnCxL6XMgO7UVG8POuB3w N7w1smXxMzfrs3hd91ZtaXiX9mBuipF4woAczJ3KsMJmSYaO0+jHU4GmnBjac51InplKmt7Kq Yf6tbjGOBI00vSRe8SrYxu2UtOpaJloVo7AWgC7HDugh+0l+40MK2kVWCX51lN19CAYvWodKo EM0E3m5kCrlP3rGeBDodFCmbFrjLJTohgcNzQpcDOqDhZEEAOrm86+TtEwsmWOHgSpTtUQ1Mh 0Hd9MIxwTVGFV0KVchvFjA1hOQAFxAX4/XgRl6HAMvPeIu21Au5yKPsQNivPYD836sXzW93UG D4shbmZa3Us8lFhdYWTinQ20+LThKe/9KizNQN/VOT47ruTUuPcIj7MUF+5G8vrW83DUySSmQ P/z1NzVyezKzVZmU1SuasIEerR/6pDqScu7go9Uc+lsYqR38VvxR5pfmGzLUv3HtdulkoJrwr tJbaHahATZudGEDvMZLD3XbDv/e+IOiyythHZTzAZ3t4ubuLWxQK1WC+en9pjBvw/35FxDSPm tNnHrnmyPO8mz4BaPr1JliyKNEe7FhPZYNq0kRVPRQfqsA93D55vQMnafNtTxjNiHQzhDb4Jk j8jp85hsn0NWYg2JqxIS4jGn7+8N8Njy1xNzwErp+DNmNxeR6C5JhwqHuHcOejXerbMUeukef t7yFAGgjLBMGyUEfLwq5XGaFT0Z/RYZhsz1o2O7FiPdxAlIJ4ETR5iXOHqrEZuRuqecQ4t+lz w9j1ZGR1XV4v8fUxdzP/c/SK4289bhafmSxNIohSgdim8/4Grb4E8V3AB7qdSCB4QUskdlJyH R7hcdUliCKnfxvDqmQnek8kNuI+vfS8Azvm+QRFpLlizVaeU7OI3Qe5Jb15VEdD2uusB9Tu6s oVVva9jtX7ANekrK9UIsTda+3HTJ4qUJ6oZQGYTcPnDHslaXWixlRGhOF7aMHsdCxDTBwpA39 HyW9X6uo5ZK+d0IUjMkgifKz1+aeBbwoaana7qpmAOsDVIut3hOp4JTKUavcZqTv1EqkSe6gr Z25Tfp9u8q6HJwRfvSjhwEufjRFYqwyT/DfCg72q3sb/8u+TxqoqVBTBsPLynSyyLdAp8qzEM 1LmmMZzBbbRoaNR27pQW6pSpz/ncJXCf4/sj0ReAo3yDoUcmxjsCTJilVjLpR0xCplV6L0tuC MXlDhtZ7TTYQ+YGNwtBStEN0Tij4KaiApgBYD2uSiDOg9GsqrUOD32mlDDD9KyCWt7c98MQXt uSLMrePGP2qETENyTZMNK4wL3m8mZ0NiyA4ctvvCOFNt5uoDQ30056TItKyWhLNMaIze83JyZ Qos22wLFyAu5ouRRk94s1R6kGQStxIRHm5RSY/h99fpfQkbL5PlQuqoTK33Fws36lTJ6FL2xk R0L6OrpWELbFFayFPGk0ETi7PEECTAOWn+3MSr4byucul5se4A6daeq3xw9eGJXzcUfn+A2qV l+FLQ2P0PNlvsOTr9qQ6qUCbznCexRz97m9WB49txNMMaBLYyTA1vTfilL2L9jlzQG/qOp1hv Yxd5/QnPrwg8orVyTtCkSk7lP2hOQLJhhqdWoJgmRdGUsu4U1CoirJuflRphraCFUvGF+E+wn e+syoEJ/bNt+IabpMMniwD/Y5pcQzHZg3S/OKqVO4VPI84kj19r3eadItRcuCQMAYXRK1JVFx hztA9kljN+aShbHSxlKgB1OB1Aw61KzFaJ0CD85IAhH8bZNGT69HBuJMGkQgHpruLx87XBXqV 91kG43j8wMHLfeGquV+koBe7zjSnNTqsJ+5QkFqB30UnY9bymvL9Wr7NL+PJlL/Z3mnLTa4i/ U1z+CMjdDtL3Dla3x4HEfsqlYhrqfqnuUMyrDwgjaI9d9hOv2T48HRxow7VaZ3GtuHl59eZth wiDeXildakkKVJxR3Eh9lF3MPHRwQtQMX0uyiUo+Ig5tQzX1c0Lm3ooa4ZChVTo1Z4dK9Bnk6 kv0CC0/VmcGWTa8OdHIHbeZhpB/1ODQS4sG5CXi/iZsMk0hVArTQ7M9fysVZnVWnesGbdGtZn eLpJR2oxmdRhEqqxGJlNtjIDaZPg4yy370AQxTCvB54EcKm2FZmceQGmTVlDu7gF7yu3dFFVc aPLFtW6b2xN31qdjxEpqj1jWumLTtjzcp+ub7RUXZX8f61tHqoPIknldPhW7d0G63RUSqFLvN btqvis7qWRCknPRZCrMFrk+BwSyuu1W24q7Q9Tqgjt3dzwK8zaTjDkU1jGiNLJrxYOcF7w0Op yZqhHSkK6YYdcsNuhNht3x4Lf8usmpOCVpvD4bxKLJrEjvpg8O2RIJlEWRKZRj+ldZBYa9FZ+ 1ap5Hdu+AFBoJuRIx6GcJlGfSFMussUAgPtcY8U9yxQETdwhC5W1CEV3gZb+sE3EbFT8XAw+p uZg04GTg9H95zScHrl9aSGNGnEJ5oslvYNZb113KcbxYEZkwf7jMXb6uWBaCw1nfNgPoQKAJl MvVpI92lcZSqkkbXicgi2lOcYudrmYIADJXoUlOxSQlZvIph62l+mte1NPNLP758fnv6kfsKA vPh01xUi2PUQvw7jdRYyICJJysN0EHvF9Ta2Ibmv4cOaphx5WcBT69JpFjA6aWXmr8V4De/wM xvLUUlipNiJjvghHrAvAQ+ppgL9u8Znj9CT4x0DGYvdLsgXfoXKBr7fcj5an2cjWJH4S3rQsO U5S7ZesrIOiWxZJ3A0O12/vI2hpuWJa1lfcf2L8axbU7AW7RozAqjw7Un+EhPPv/29z7UeJVn 3jUtazWaJDD08TUbWhOi2B5PKuZ/Q1AgxGR0tgyOSHRICl0Pnjw53uynBQnXP+x0DFFKVVdId cBLiLNlhrNa/sbAbglO+OGOYg/ubrD46m183+hergO4jfo8Mc/eyvnsNIP4Q4MvydSaEPIRB/ On35SSlyV4AOp3V1hBMRut41rNE7VkL7xcLZLrghSdZX2TEpzn4ZFmx4MKuSm3w4jLZSReQwW oDm+zEQLb2FGUFSIbpqQFhMliRybCGuIqECyL3fFe79CAWkrmBhqxpt9iHuRdX7Q9Q6gM1FO1 0EeyIk+rTvDy2imk3L67CvUf+aXYfbJ8TIkMxW5FA+BgGmVZ5iFk0nqOx4TeH2KQqccpsgw9Q PSKsMCyI6wsH7XtMKTBTSB4RGWPLMQArDmrYe90yOCSmq8iuWOQ4Z5pk5ibJaYN3JWDzNSY3R W/AQVEP5X8Jz68JUCAcKw6cMo3DjSnExcydhYhAF/EqsTwLKtQV7KhBw8SuIsbn9ieeq9Ge2J VrL0etluuZFW6XqfZEkffwxJm/C1AHhz4fbkSxhAN8S9cKC98BaJdcBo67Fl3PgL5AqSO3xgo nXHTSUe4bif2R50XOu69H7rglWE6I82aR55XLag/ycZLnSSpFLPZoRv7XPyvFtMndd1M4zKYp plGwjx7n3lU/ns+Ksb/gEP8hKuSLinnKK2qGrrmeRMEGOYZjz2LOUJxrKg93ux9tqz/R2CaWv uTZL0TK/7XfjzsuBWKeaqIfVyOyDvj8aab+imiGKPxhZ4wCcpGQ9Af9ihDne+YjYP9ln0fi56 p1iWB4W4gP1bv1/VxBeKIxwjeqskPQoBhP3A8owzrQ3UlNGvqOWrc/4w02s1YLvEtF9wxHI5p s+dyJzxytAYBUOPyfyTYka+Ge/pqwbKwZ0p1lHZUmMoQnUIBO5aXqgehy/RPDvy0wM86yB436 2OixCgz5yUo2wUBevMoryvvJ/c2l/0joqieBhGKerF+QBlaInZI6KU0Ps2YbiTQRu/1gI9MQD U7pDoTK1UJzqp6wRTR2o2DFmrpKZuVt6jZFA1w7g+V0uyATxBG+/zUvSto7luQABzCIzff4ZL mVk9XSrcH0/2E7Fq3vqlF2vqXxod0a75kcrfdvAD5WvAG1jnXyC/39bS+7X7Gz/U0eyPkXilK KK6RxgdKjGDtOlm3hpAqEDtd6RO3gCpDzh7bxtohLpxavqVEwH4NPeF7l90o3qVgv/wbpqyq2 z10QccawdZTiWIUPgLXTezixJHa3mGaLMmgt1AHJAklA5A4DEyE34ouVkvcfsN5qQ8hjSHYtJ 4y8iyQYj+BsxPB9rAIGoZKQSdjvO1nV/DQCTxQeZjpim9xqeDi6w4rHB5+hbEakOmyHECa46r /i0V5qRsNn7w+WEs2VM+JXo+4RzAvFryV3UScHcUmh8C4XZ3+ovolZpzv1mo6l/joggCMmJdv jtJm5Bw/opLYoG/2JoNs3wistuTnGz4q2g+7BAu7sBPOfAvhxbLP9hHzcRh+4CqcQWniYThUN XSB3O4ZQR/Jz2ckTMrktm+NbrEw2z0gjwf4Es4uLdEaTkKQSOcb0Dd14vJGpivw7mY2+813vg vv2Ez0qoEdh5SSNRXDjK2iXbxG2ZOSOY6hA2rrGwQCFTSEWqIaef8v6Wbaz34synNo7EzRUtd sb8xyCLJki2Bj9hL21beHimowQGE8mN5L73rFP9f9PbmiT8PkoMcbqxbRLg73ytRTdFHro8Dl OSxIsaUSbukyc9mBRAzfjbzJVEjWXPQJNXpYMKskbImxlconmWOach4OQaaggpEbbHFTXWuxL 8pHcZd5H2JxAIHgUC0UM8udff0YByaJnI5nj1p4grG4YFSbccIFnBBOh21IG8tOhrA0Ptnmwi 11uc16Ld6VO+DjvI5jIGZSQv9Pg7RvlywuxWBx4YGwUlddmZRfnfprVz9dW7uM0byCoRTQ+ws D5WO2YU+zPcoHAfwB4Py5nyB7p9rHOElRIsNC8bhWRcetrqoKPB97HqePIs+8gtDb2ucMz+kE bRF2+rG1e7M2t25XmKssaO6BeZXOZl4oPKcLlgqD0FEgZP6m0GPD5fGOSe7T/SW+PzRv+WzaM Ito/+geo2eqz7m+X6+ycOOtEqb/ST9nK5nEYRJwk5JzTYrTLI26KZ08QdLBzB2FdqJfDoHl8I 3Ne46wKt4l8W1KpoAM4kOWUHqQWDBcw82tlTY2oQlZuw== Content-Transfer-Encoding: quoted-printable On Tue, Sep 29, 2026 at 03:21:25PM +0200, Takashi Iwai wrote: > On Sat, 19 Sep 2026 17:18:37 +0200, > Christian Ruppert wrote: > >=20 > > This patch set adds support for advanced mixer features of the Audient > > EVO4 audio interface. The code is structured so that support for the > > EVO8 (and potentially other Audient devices) should be trivial to add > > but I don't have access to the hardware and no way of testing them so > > they are not supported by this patch set. > >=20 > > The third patch in the series (Add Kconfig option for Audient EVO4 mix= er > > quirks) is optional. Other mixer quirks are compiled in by default and > > don't provide Kconfig options but as this one adds a few hundred lines > > of code I decided to provide this last patch as an option and leave th= e > > choice if such an option should be added to the subsystem maintainers. > >=20 > > Christian Ruppert (3): > > Fix Audient EVO4 master playback control name > > Add Audient EVO4 mixer quirks > > Add Kconfig option for Audient EVO4 mixer quirks >=20 > I merged the two, but dropped the Kconfig patch. >=20 > We have no Kconfig for other mixer stuff, and most likely the users > will enable simply all mixer supported devices. >=20 > It might make sense to introduce a Kconfig if we build each vendor > mixer stuff as an individual module, though. Until then, let's try > to reduce Kconfig. Thanks, makes perfect sense. Thanks to Faaris for testing everything! > BTW, do you see an issue Faaris reported for the recent kernel? This situation is actually more subtle than I originally thought, I replied to this in the other thread here: https://lore.kernel.org/regressions/arwVedydsKxSgpho@khmer.arcnet/ Christian