Re: ANNOUNCE: User-space System Device Enumation (uSDE)

[Andreas Jellinghaus <aj@dungeon.inka.de>]

On Tue, 28 Oct 2003 22:52:33 +0000, Greg KH wrote:
> For SDE:
> $ find . -type f | egrep '[.c|.h]$' | xargs wc -l | tail -1
>   57328 total
...

> For udev:
> $ find . -type f | egrep '[.c|.h]$' | xargs wc -l | tail -1
>   17632 total

Here is a config file and a 41 lines shell script, that
will populate /udev with all devices found via /sys.
A version to add or remove only one file should be about
the same size.

---cat /etc/makedev.conf---
ttyS0 root dialout 0660
zero root root 0666
null root root 0666

---cat makedev---
#!/bin/sh

set -e

DEV=/udev
CONFIG=/etc/makedev.conf

cd $DEV

find /sys/class -name dev |while read A;
do
	B=`dirname $A`
	B=`basename $B`
	MM=`cat $A|tr ":" " "`
	mknod --mode=0600 $B c $MM
	if grep -q "$B " $CONFIG
	then
		USER=`grep "$B " $CONFIG|cut -d" " -f2`
		GROUP=`grep "$B " $CONFIG|cut -d" " -f3`
		MODE=`grep "$B " $CONFIG|cut -d" " -f4`
		chown $USER.$GROUP $B
		chmod $MODE $B
	fi
done

find /sys/block -name dev |while read A;
do
	B=`dirname $A`
	B=`basename $B`
	MM=`cat $A|tr ":" " "`
	mknod --mode=0600 $B b $MM
	if grep -q "$B " $CONFIG
	then
		USER=`grep "$B " $CONFIG|cut -d" " -f2`
		GROUP=`grep "$B " $CONFIG|cut -d" " -f3`
		MODE=`grep "$B " $CONFIG|cut -d" " -f4`
		chown $USER.$GROUP $B
		chmod $MODE $B
	fi
done
---cut---

So udev is 99% overhead?

sure, it's fast and small, and has lots of features that I don't need.

> 	SDE:	57328 lines
> 	udev:	 9090 lines
 shell script:     41 lines

> that udev is suffering from "lack of maintainability and bloat" if you
> really want :)

bloat. lots of bloat. what is that tdb database for?
filesystems are persistent. if you want to save space,
create a tar file :-) 

> p.s. yes, I know lines of code is a horrible metric, and doesn't really
> mean squat.  I just want to point out the huge size difference between
> the current state of udev and SDE, with pretty much identical
> functionality from what I can tell.

I agree. lines of codes is a horrible metric, and comparing a shell
script that uses many external commands to a c application with
everything build is makes absolutely no sense. but I wonder why
the off the shelf machine needs a c applications, if all those
external commands are installed anyway.

Regards, Andreas