ACPI poweroff problem with 2.4.x on VIA chipset M/B

ACPI poweroff problem with 2.4.x on VIA chipset M/B

[나상옥]

Hello everyone,

My machine has ASUS CUV4X-E mainboard with Award BIOS.
Using poweroff command, I can power off my machine
with kernel 2.2.x.
But with kernel 2.4.x, this machine doesn't change
to soft-off(S5) state after poweroff command enters.
The last message is "Could not enter S5".
However, old via-chipset mainboard machine has
no problem to poweroff with kernel 2.4.x.

I found 2.3.x VIA chipset patch for ACPI.
Is there 2.4.x VIA chipser pach for ACPI?

Please CC any replies to my email address
becausen I am not subscribed to linux-kernel

- nso
---
SangOg Na

RE: ACPI poweroff problem with 2.4.x on VIA chipset M/B

[Grover, Andrew]

No there isn't a chipset patch for ACPI, because IMHO vendor-specific code
is the wrong way to go regarding this. ACPI defines how shutdown should
happen, and if it doesn't work on a given system, then either the code has
a bug or the hardware is not ACPI compliant.

(I think the ACPI code has a bug, but it's not immediately obvious to me
how to fix it, since we are doing what the spec says, so what more can we
do?)

Regards -- Andy

> From: nso@icu.ac.kr [mailto:nso@icu.ac.kr]
> My machine has ASUS CUV4X-E mainboard with Award BIOS.
> Using poweroff command, I can power off my machine
> with kernel 2.2.x.
> But with kernel 2.4.x, this machine doesn't change
> to soft-off(S5) state after poweroff command enters.
> The last message is "Could not enter S5".
> However, old via-chipset mainboard machine has
> no problem to poweroff with kernel 2.4.x.
> 
> I found 2.3.x VIA chipset patch for ACPI.
> Is there 2.4.x VIA chipser pach for ACPI?
> 
> Please CC any replies to my email address
> becausen I am not subscribed to linux-kernel