register_timer_hook fails on realtime kernel with CONFIG_PROFILE_NMI

register_timer_hook fails on realtime kernel with CONFIG_PROFILE_NMI

[John Kacur]

Hi,
I wrote a "Very Simple Timer Notification Module", which calls
register_timer_hook to register a function to be called using the timer
interrupt. This is essentially what OProfile would do in timer interrupt
mode. The standard kernel allows you to do this even if
CONFIG_PROFILE_NMI is defined but the realtime kernel does not. With the
realtime kernel register_timer_hook succeeds but the timer hooks is
never called. From patch-2.6.17-rt8 the following modifies
linux/include/linux/clockchips.h
+#ifndef CONFIG_PROFILE_NMI
+#define CLOCK_CAP_PROFILE	0x000008
+#else
+#define CLOCK_CAP_PROFILE	0x000000
+#endif

So, it's simple enough to work around, by just making CLOCK_CAP_PROFILE
0x000008 regardless of whether CONFIG_PROFILE_NMI is defined or not, but
I would like to understand the intention of the authors here. Is there a
good reason to disallow the timer interrupt mode of profiling if
CONFIG_PROFILE_NMI is defined? (other than arguing that NMI profiling is
superior)

I have included vstnm.tar.bz2 in case it is of any help examinig the
problem. Just do:
tar xjf vstnm.tar.bz2
cd vstnm
make
make install
then use the script load_vstnm to load the module and unload_vstnm to
unload the module. If the timer_tick function is called it will print a
rate limited message to the console that it was called.

Thank you

Re: register_timer_hook fails on realtime kernel with CONFIG_PROFILE_NMI

[John Kacur]

[-- Attachment #1: Type: text/plain, Size: 113 bytes --]


> I have included vstnm.tar.bz2 in case it is of any help examinig the

This time I'll acually include it. :)



[-- Attachment #2: vstnm.tar.bz2 --]
[-- Type: application/x-bzip-compressed-tar, Size: 918 bytes --]