* Re: BSD-Linux FlameWar over SoftRAID
@ 2001-09-26 14:12 Warner Losh
0 siblings, 0 replies; 5+ messages in thread
From: Warner Losh @ 2001-09-26 14:12 UTC (permalink / raw)
To: linux-kernel
[[ This message is sent as a private person and is not an official
statement from FreeBSD's core team. ]]
: It is clear that BSD is going off the deep end.
Actually, I'm on the FreeBSD core team. BSD is not going off the deep
end. People in slashdot are going off the deep end. The reporter
that reported it didn't bother to do his homework. The reporter erred
in not checking with those in the Linux development efforts to find if
the issue had been resolved. The fact that it had been resolved at
least 12 hours before the story hit slashdot (I saw pointers to
patches which corrected the problems posted to an IRC channel the
night before I saw it on slashdot).
The fact of the matter is that the code was copied from FreeBSD
verbatium, or with minor alterations. That's not a problem at all,
since our license allows for that. The problem came in that Soren's
name was removed from the headers which he'd put a lot of time into.
The problem was corrected, no big deal except for the weirdos on
slashdot.
FreeBSD's core team has never issued any statements on this issue, nor
have we made any demands. Frankly, I think that this is way overblown
as well. People should remember that slashdot isn't reality and that
it should be taken with a grain of salt.
Healthy code and concept sharing between Linux and FreeBSD (and
between any opensource groups) is in everyone's best interest to
continue the cooperative competition that we've had in the past.
I won't address the supposed borrowing from Linux -> FreeBSD in the
IDE driver in the head of this thread, since I've not done any
research on that topic. I do know Soren has access to all the IDE/ATA
specs and is bright enough to dig what's necessary out of them. Let's
be careful of tossing accusations of theft in a public forum when it
is possible that he figured it out himself. Prior availability in
Linux doesn't mean that later groups necessarily took anything from
Linux to make their code work. Let's not loose sight of the fact that
there's plenty of bright people with good will who do good work in
both groups.
So take a deep breath and realize that this isn't the end of the
world.
Warner Losh
[[ who released ObjectBuilder for Linux as the first (or one of the
first) "demoware" product for Linux back in 1992 or 1993 and did
some Linux/Mips work. He now happens to be the FreeBSD pccard
maintainer and in FreeBSD's governing body named core. ]]
^ permalink raw reply [flat|nested] 5+ messages in thread
* Re: BSD-Linux FlameWar over SoftRAID.
2001-09-26 7:03 Andre Hedrick
2001-09-26 8:55 ` Alexander Viro
@ 2001-09-26 16:13 ` Alan Cox
2001-09-26 16:04 ` Andre Hedrick
1 sibling, 1 reply; 5+ messages in thread
From: Alan Cox @ 2001-09-26 16:13 UTC (permalink / raw)
To: Andre Hedrick; +Cc: lkml, Linus Torvalds, Alan Cox, Arjan van de Ven
> It is clear that BSD is going off the deep end.
Andre - 99% of the BSD developers are sane reasonable people. They have
their kooks we have ours. Since both headers appear to be representations
of a third party datastructure the matter is also completely irrelevant.
I would suggest folks read up a little on copyright law with regard to
interfaces and definitions.
Now if Arjan did copy the stuff by reference to the BSD drivers, then no
he didn't do anything wrong - but I agree it would have been polite to have
duly credited it. It would also have been polite if the BSD person concerned
had contacted him privately and asked too
Alan
^ permalink raw reply [flat|nested] 5+ messages in thread
* Re: BSD-Linux FlameWar over SoftRAID.
2001-09-26 16:13 ` Alan Cox
@ 2001-09-26 16:04 ` Andre Hedrick
0 siblings, 0 replies; 5+ messages in thread
From: Andre Hedrick @ 2001-09-26 16:04 UTC (permalink / raw)
To: Alan Cox; +Cc: lkml, Linus Torvalds, Arjan van de Ven
Alan,
The real problem is that the header content is incomplete and wrong for
complete feature usage. I will write a signature header file for the
various flavors and document the ownership of the IP and the terms of
usage.
This should be an optimal solution.
I gather you are point to me as the 1% for the Linux KOOKs ;-)
Cheers,
Andre Hedrick
CTO ASL, Inc.
Linux ATA Development
-----------------------------------------------------------------------------
ASL, Inc. Tel: (510) 857-0055 x103
38875 Cherry Street Fax: (510) 857-0010
Newark, CA 94560 Web: www.aslab.com
On Wed, 26 Sep 2001, Alan Cox wrote:
> > It is clear that BSD is going off the deep end.
>
> Andre - 99% of the BSD developers are sane reasonable people. They have
> their kooks we have ours. Since both headers appear to be representations
> of a third party datastructure the matter is also completely irrelevant.
> I would suggest folks read up a little on copyright law with regard to
> interfaces and definitions.
>
> Now if Arjan did copy the stuff by reference to the BSD drivers, then no
> he didn't do anything wrong - but I agree it would have been polite to have
> duly credited it. It would also have been polite if the BSD person concerned
> had contacted him privately and asked too
>
> Alan
>
^ permalink raw reply [flat|nested] 5+ messages in thread
* Re: BSD-Linux FlameWar over SoftRAID.
2001-09-26 7:03 Andre Hedrick
@ 2001-09-26 8:55 ` Alexander Viro
2001-09-26 16:13 ` Alan Cox
1 sibling, 0 replies; 5+ messages in thread
From: Alexander Viro @ 2001-09-26 8:55 UTC (permalink / raw)
To: Andre Hedrick; +Cc: lkml
On Wed, 26 Sep 2001, Andre Hedrick wrote:
> It is clear that BSD is going off the deep end.
s/BSD/slashdotters/, s/is going/had gone/ and wasn't it obvious for years?
> Linux ATA Development has a Legal signed NDA for the proper development of
> the complete and correct FastTrak(tm) open sources driver.
>
> I will soon publish the complete header codes in a original header w/
> a Linux ATA Development Copyright and Promise Technologies Copyright.
> The driver will have a GPL statement be issued in the headers and source
> files to prevent the usage in BSDish environments. I have not tolerance
> for being labled a thief.
... by slashdorks. It's scary, actually - if they can affect you, what
effect can be produced by more respectable publications? Like, say it,
Star or National Enquirer...
^ permalink raw reply [flat|nested] 5+ messages in thread
* BSD-Linux FlameWar over SoftRAID.
@ 2001-09-26 7:03 Andre Hedrick
2001-09-26 8:55 ` Alexander Viro
2001-09-26 16:13 ` Alan Cox
0 siblings, 2 replies; 5+ messages in thread
From: Andre Hedrick @ 2001-09-26 7:03 UTC (permalink / raw)
To: lkml; +Cc: Linus Torvalds, Alan Cox, Arjan van de Ven
It is clear that BSD is going off the deep end.
Linux ATA Development has a Legal signed NDA for the proper development of
the complete and correct FastTrak(tm) open sources driver.
I will soon publish the complete header codes in a original header w/
a Linux ATA Development Copyright and Promise Technologies Copyright.
The driver will have a GPL statement be issued in the headers and source
files to prevent the usage in BSDish environments. I have not tolerance
for being labled a thief.
I will prove the point that Linux does not "STEAL IP", then watch BSD
"borrow" from Linux. Just like we will watch 48-BIT Addressing be
borrowed without credit. Just like we will watch the new Ultra133 drivers
be borrowed without credit. BSD has no legal documentation to develop
these changes or access to hardware. We will watch and prove where IP
comes from in the world of storage.
Ever noticed how Linux had Ultra100 support 10 minutes after the release
of public information on June 5, 2000 8:00am PDT?
For now the Linux Open Source drivers for SoftRAID need to go away.
Not to worry they will return in full swing.
**********************
Date: Wed, 10 Nov 1999 11:32:52 -0800
From: ---deleted---
To: 'Andre Hedrick' <andre@suse.com>
Subject: RE: [Research] FastTrak66 Ultra ATA/66
Hi Andre,
Very interesting work, I can't guess how you did it. Here is our beta
driver for the Fasttrak. This is the one I told you about. It uses our Raid
engine (engine3.a). Sorry, but as I mentioned there is no possibility of us
releasing the source code for this. However you can get a good idea of how
the engine works by viewing our driver source. Please do not distribute
this driver or the engine binary to anyone. I've included some quick
documentation too, I remember there is one step missing but it is obvious.
begin 600 FT03.TGZ
M'XL(`);\_C<``^0\:W/;1I+^BE3E/XR5DA:D(!&DJ$=$05L42=FL6(](\N:R
M.16*)$ ):Q)@`-"6UO;^]NON>6 `@HQLV55W=4Q,`3,],ST]_9J>'F[77GSW
<BIG SNIP>
M`UT#``-=`P`#70,``UT#``-=`P`%5@%=`P`%5@%=`P`%5@%=`P`%5@%=`P`%
35@%=`P`%5@%=`P`%5@%=`P``%@`%
`
end
**********************
Here is the proof that I could have done this long before the BSD folks
had a clue about soft raid engines wrt addon cards.
Regards,
Andre Hedrick
CTO ASL, Inc.
Linux ATA Development
-----------------------------------------------------------------------------
ASL, Inc. Tel: (510) 857-0055 x103
38875 Cherry Street Fax: (510) 857-0010
Newark, CA 94560 Web: www.aslab.com
^ permalink raw reply [flat|nested] 5+ messages in thread
end of thread, other threads:[~2001-09-26 16:20 UTC | newest]
Thread overview: 5+ messages (download: mbox.gz / follow: Atom feed)
-- links below jump to the message on this page --
2001-09-26 14:12 BSD-Linux FlameWar over SoftRAID Warner Losh
-- strict thread matches above, loose matches on Subject: below --
2001-09-26 7:03 Andre Hedrick
2001-09-26 8:55 ` Alexander Viro
2001-09-26 16:13 ` Alan Cox
2001-09-26 16:04 ` Andre Hedrick
This is a public inbox, see mirroring instructions
for how to clone and mirror all data and code used for this inbox
all inboxes | Powered by JetHome®