Re: support for offset > 2GB on x86 in losetup needed

Re: support for offset > 2GB on x86 in losetup needed

[Matthew Wilcox]

Hi, Vlad

You wrote:
> Currently linux-2.4 on x86 doesn't allow to use offsets greater than 2GB
> for losetup utility. Looking at the code, it turns out that the kernel is
> guilty - linux kernel doesn't allow offsets greater than 2Gb since it uses
> 32-bit wide signed (why signed?) integer for storing the offset on x86..
>
> That's a very severe limitation IMHO, it would be very nice to fix this in
> 2.5 at least (but it would be better to fix it in 2.4 of course :).

That's right, the current ioctl API passes an `int' between userspace
and the kernel.  I'm currently working on a major rewrite of this code,
based on suggestions by Al Viro.

The new API will be:

mount -t loop -o offset=1234567890,rw foo.iso /dev/loop0

However I only started on this code last week, so I'm not quite done yet ;-)

Currently unsolved problem: encryption.  I'm certain people are not
comfortable supplying their keys on the command line, available to
anyone using ps.  So one option would be a 'key=file' option, but that
doesn't allow people to protect that with a passphrase (people _do_
use that feature, right?).  Next option is a `keyfd=N', but then we
need a losetup program, which invokes mount(2) rather than an ioctl.
Perhaps that's acceptable.

Other bright ideas urgently sought ;-)

-- 
Revolutions do not require corporate support.

support for offset > 2GB on x86 in losetup needed

[Vlad Harchev]

 Hello, 

 Currently linux-2.4 on x86  doesn't allow to use offsets greater than 2GB
for losetup utility. Looking at the code, it turns out that the kernel is
guilty - linux kernel doesn't allow offsets greater than 2Gb since it uses
32-bit wide signed (why signed?) integer for storing the offset on x86..

 That's a very severe limitation IMHO, it would be very nice to fix this in
2.5 at least (but it would be better to fix it in 2.4 of course :).

 What do you think about this?

PS: I'm not on the list, so please cc replies to me.

 Best regards,
  -Vlad